Jump to content

Garreg Mach

  • entries
    1,066
  • comments
    5,317
  • views
    729,194

The Pixar List - Brave - Rank 5


Voltex

640 views

brave.png

5th - Brave, 2012

iBrow Percentage: 90 (Revised)

 

Brave is a beauty, with its abundance of greens and blues and purples, and other soft or cool hues within the surroundings and the characters. This helps the main character, Merida, to stand out with her flaming orange hair. The film was one of my most anticipated this year, and I originally scored it with an 87% in a review. My reasons for upgrading it were because, during July (whilst preparing to do this list), I re-watched Brave, Toy Story, Toy Story 2, Wall-E, Cars, Finding Nemo, and The Incredibles to refresh my memory, having seen the other Pixar films at some point in the last year. While doing this, I realized that the film is just better in several aspects. The musical score, while not something I'd listen to outside of watching the film was a pleasure to hear during it, and helped to set the film apart.The animation is truly spectacular and possibly the best Pixar has ever done - the only Pixar film that could challenge this is Finding Nemo.

 

While most people seemed to feel that the relationship between Merida and her mother was just a redx of the one between Nemo and his fater (except not as good), I found that it set itself apart and was entertaining enough to be considered in its own right. If we're talking parent to child relationships, Brave is the one I would want to see. The firey tempers of both characters, who are both right in different ways, is far more appealng than Nemo and his father. I found Merida's relationship to be far more dynamic from the start, as well - right after their first major onscreen spat we see both of them on their own, regretting the argument and wishing they knew how to fix it.

 

The major faults of the film are the story and the characters. The story seems rushed and cramped - Merida and her mother are built up as the only characters you need to really care about, and the two treat everyone else (with the exception of the King and the Witch) as a mindless mob. I think the film's story could have benefitted from being lengthened by thirty minutes and giving the rest of the cast more of a spotlight.

 

That said, the characters are also my favourite aspect of the film aside from the beautiful animation. Merida herself is certainly one of Pixar's more interesting characters, but my favourites are the Witch and the King. The King's clueless but fearless nature had me laughing out loud whenever he said something funny, and the Witch was the same. Her matter of act nature and her resigned warnings to Merida's deaf ears made every scene she was in a treat.

 

Anyway, those are my thoughts on Brave, a month and a half late. Feel free to disagree in the comments below, and I promise to have Rank 4 ready sooner. =P

No more hints, but for those of you late or not paying attention, the following films must still be ranked:

Toy Story 3 - Toy Story 2 - Finding Nemo - The Incredibles

2 Comments


Recommended Comments

:kaukau: YES! I actually would rank this at 5 as well, so I thought it was really awesome when I saw this here.

 

As for some of the other characters...no, I wasn't really invested in them, but on the other hand I was still entertained by them, and the characterization of some of them was still pretty strong nevertheless. Now personally I find that Brave was just the length it needed to be, although I could see this being a Hobbit of sorts to a larger Lord of the Rings-eque epic.

 

And Yesssssssss! Finding Nemo and two of the Toy Story films are in the top four. The Incredibles is also worthy. I wouldn't have it any other way (this is, of course, presuming that Finding Nemo ranks higher than The Incredibles, which is a close call so it's not that significant, and one of the Toy Story movies is #1).

 

24601

Link to comment

Brave put me off when they decided to toss in some crude jokes which I have, in the past, considered to be the stuff of DreamWorks or Disney. At the same time, the movie failed to communicate to me exactly where the relationship changed between Merida and Elinor. My best guess would be in the forest shortly after escaping the castle, (and that's probably correct) but it seemed more to me like as soon as the Queen went presto-change-o, all the mother-daughter problems were solved (the magic spell problems on the other hand...). Plus, it seemed to me like the only character that changed was the queen--Merida's part in healing the breach was all related to that magic spell rather than in their actual relationship.

 

But the high points are definitely in the animation. PIXAR has had few more challenging environments, and usually, those are restricted to a single scene. (Like the door vault in Monsters, Inc. or Syndrome's Island in the Incredibles.) They killed it on Brave.

Link to comment
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...