Jump to content
  • entries
    316
  • comments
    1,489
  • views
    199,897

The Nanny Plague


Makuta_of_Oz

851 views

Please note: Despite the following rant, I am not racist. Please also note that this is going to be a very long entry.

 

victims_of_the_nanny_plague_1_by_machop_fan-d3hz7fe.jpg

 

Over the past decade, the Nanny Plague that has been spreading throughout the countries of the west has slowly been eating away at Pokemon from within. In the good old days Pokemon had a much higher target audience, but America misinterpreted it, thinking Pokemon is for little kids when it's really meant for people over the age of 10 (under-10s can also play it, as I did back in the day, but they weren't quite the target audience), and that has resulted in so many good aspects of Pokemon being ruined.

 

Two of the most well-known victims of this plague are black Jynx and slot machines/coin-buying.

 

No-one in my age group who watched the Anime back then would have ever thought that Jynx could've been racist. The only person who thought that was a racist American called Carole Boston Weatherford. She was responsible for giving Jynx a bad name, making Jynx what it never was - a racist figure. While you're at it, why not ban Umbreon too? It's black!

 

The slot machines of generations past definitely did not encourage gambling. I talk from experience. I was below the target age group when I got Yellow, and was 9 when I played those machines for the first time. Nowadays I avoid real-life slot machines whenever I encounter them. Even when I visited an RSL with my nan once a week, and was given $2 AUD to spend on their slot machines, I'd just take the $2 and leave because Pokemon's slot machines taught me that playing slot machines for money is not worth it. All Pokemon players know that it's way more worth one's time to buy coins and pretend the slot machines didn't exist, because it's so much easier and faster that way (In DPPt one can get 10,000 coins in half an hour without using the machines).

 

Pokemon, however, is not the only sign of the Nanny Plague. Just look around in real life, and you can't miss it.

 

In my day, Year 12s used to spend their last day of school before exams having fun, dressing up, and playing various pranks on the school. We used to call that day "Muck-up Day". Then came the Nanny Plague. Now teachers think that name encourages long-term violence and crime, and we were forced to call in "Celebration Day"!

 

Back in the olden days, nearly every cartoon had slapstick violence. Then came the Nanny Plague. Now people think that slapstick violence encourages real-life violence, and slapstick violence is seldom seen. When it appears in movies, they now give warnings under classifications, which they never did before.

 

Ask yourself, are you racist because you've seen black Jynx? Are you a problem gambler because you've played gambling minigames in video and computer games? Have you become violent because of Muck-up Day or equivalent, or because you watched cartoons with slapstick violence?

16 Comments


Recommended Comments

I agree, society has become overprotective - and not in a good way. Anything even remotely offensive is supposed to be removed. When my dad was a kid, he'd drive a mile or so to a convenience store on his bike (no pads) to get candy. Now, you'd be considered a bad parent if you let a kid do that.

Link to comment

You seem to be misunderstanding the Jynx issue. The episode in question had Jynx as a nurse, and it was a concern that it would be seen as a derogatory stereotype, and could possibly affect impressionable young viewers into believing racial and gender stereotypes are okay. I think the change did have a certain degree of merit, really. It was not a pointless disagreement with all Pokemon that use the color black in their appearance, which is a rather poor straw man argument to use. Also, I'd say the name "Nanny Plague" appears a pejorative construct to attract criticism.

 

Also, Jynx has white arms.

 

~B~

Link to comment

You seem to be misunderstanding the Jynx issue. The episode in question had Jynx as a nurse, and it was a concern that it would be seen as a derogatory stereotype, and could possibly affect impressionable young viewers into believing racial and gender stereotypes are okay. I think the change did have a certain degree of merit, really. It was not a pointless disagreement with all Pokemon that use the color black in their appearance, which is a rather poor straw man argument to use. Also, I'd say the name "Nanny Plague" appears a pejorative construct to attract criticism. Also, Jynx has white arms. ~B~

Actually, Jynx caused a second episode, called Holiday Hi-Jynx, to be banned because heaps of black Jynx appeared in it. The fact that they all worked as Santa's helpers seemingly meant nothing. Plus, at least two episodes featuring Jynx had it cut out; one in the Orange Islands saga and one in the Hoenn saga.

 

Before Jynx was made purple, she had red arms and blue hands and feet. They were changed along with Jynx's skin when she was redesigned.

Link to comment

http://en.wikipedia....y_and_reception Jynx was racist and closely resembled blackface.

Jynx was never intended to be racist. She was based off a fashion style that was popular in Japan at the time. Ganguro, it was called.

 

[Don't link to sites with forums. -Shine] <-- This article explains Jynx's origin and interpretations well.

Link to comment

You know Ganguto literally translates to blackface right?

 

 

It doesn't carry the same meaning in Japan so it was more acceptable there however its completely unacceptable in most of the west especially the US.

Link to comment

Laughin'Man: [Do not mention sites with forums. -Takuma Nuva] is biased?

 

Jonestown Bartender: I did realise that when I read through the article again.

 

The problem here is America. They want to claim everything as their own, Pokemon included. That's why they rejected Japan's culture and called them racist. Japan has since been forced to adapt to the control freak country's culture (not the other way around like it should've been), but Jynx's debut episode aired before the Pokemon Anime went to America.

 

BTW we're getting off-topic. This is not an entry about racism, this is an entry about the Nanny Plague, hence why there are slot machines in that picture.

Link to comment

it's a Pokemon fansite, so of course it's going to be slanted to portray the Jynx issue in a positive light. so yes, it's biased.

Link to comment

Actually Japan copied blackface from the US post WW2 when it was popular and socially acceptable.

 

If you think this is what cultural imperialism looks like you need to read more.

Link to comment

All other media must adjust to each country that it is debuted in. Why should Japan not follow said rules and realize what's acceptable and not in each country? Eitherway, Blackface was a racist term originally but has been changed otherwise.

Link to comment

Occupation. I see. That makes sense.

 

On-topic: Can anyone else think of any examples of governments or councils gone mad that overprotects children?

Link to comment

Not really considering you're making a huge fuss over something done by a privet industry and then the name change of an event.

 

Don't you have anything better to do then whine to the internet?

Link to comment
Guest
This blog entry is now closed to further comments.
×
×
  • Create New...