Jump to content

believe victims

Members
  • Posts

    3,292
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    55

Posts posted by believe victims

  1.  

    You know, I went back and starting rebuilding all of my Bionicle sets for no particular reason, and I was kind of shocked at the sheer amount of clone sets. While the Toa Mata/Nuva/Metru at least have some diversity, the Tohunga, Bohrok, Bohrok Kal, Rahkshi, Vahki, Visorak, Hordika, Piraka, and Inika hardly have any at all - the only thing differentiating any of them are different tools, colors, and occasionally a piece or two. 

     

    Now, I am not saying that I hate clone sets - I am especially fond of the Tohunga - but really? Was there a need for such a lack of diversity? I mean, building them was more monotonous than you could believe!

     

    Post thoughts

    I see a problem there. Mata were just as cloney as the Inika.

     

    Hrm. For some reason, I don't quite agree with that, if only because the Mata had two stand-out variations (Pohatu's upside-down gearbox and Onua's hunched stature), as well as more varied weapons (with actual differences in structure and utility, rather than Sword Or Gun), while the Inika's variation was pretty much entirely limited to what pieces were used as opposed to how they were used.

     

    I mean, both were still pretty clone-y, and I definitely don't agree that the Metru had more variation than the Inika (since outside of varied molds, literally the only thing setting the Metru apart was torso length), but I don't think the Mata were just as clone-y, since their individual builds still had an element of diversity to them that the Inika simply discarded.

     

     

    I'm pretty sure there was another topic along these lines before.  I think clones are fine if you have combiners, then you can build said combiners with whatever same-wave sets you have.

     

    Also - this is just me - but clone waves kinda look like a uniform of some sorts.  To me it makes sense all the Toa on one team have similar armor, it's their distinguished 'team' look.  The Bohrok are all the same basic type of minion, the Rahkshi are the same brood, so on and so forth.

     

    I don't think sets necessarily need to be clones to look like they belong on the same team. The 2015 Toa all had shared motifs, such as their piston armor, similar tool aesthetics, and chest patterns, that drew them together visually as belonging to the same team, while still having varied builds with individual personality.

     

    For something like the Bohrok, where they're intended to be a literal swarm of identical creatures, I don't think being clone sets was all that bad, because yeah, it made sense. But for Toa, where individual personality matters as much as, if not more than, team cohesion, being exact clones of each other is more of a detriment than a benefit.

    • Upvote 1
  2. Bionicle G2 apologists who will also support the theory of Ekimu being evil, but god forbid the fact it could be a continuation would actually do the story any justice...

     

    Beware oversimplification of the opposing side. "G2 apologists" are not some monolithic entity, and I'm pretty sure most of the people I've seen disagreeing with you in this topic also disagree with overhashed "what if good guy is bad guy" theories.

    • Upvote 5
  3. >not being a liberal

    Bigoted

     

    That's very tolerant of you

     

    Eh? Where'd you get that from? I just meant treating other people as lesser based on their gender, sexuality, skin color, etc. That's the very definition of bigotry. It's what BZPower doesn't allow, and it's what 4chan revels in. Anything political you're reading into it is on you.

     

    edit: sorry, made this post before I saw Windrider's warning.

    • Upvote 3
  4. What disgusts me most is that there are so many people out there that claim BZPower to be the "4chan of the Bionicle community", yet, from what I've seen, we're probably the most relaxed out of all major Bionicle fan-sites; There's not many, if any, arguments going on.

     

    Considering the same person complains about BZP having "more 'SJWS'", I am perfectly content to dunk their opinion in the garbage where it belongs. Outside of some past heated discussions, BZPower's progressiveness only really shows itself in its intolerance policies (which any civil forum should have), or the occasional more nuanced look at the story.

     

    (And, as Lyichir pointed out, being more progressive than other Bionicle sites would be the opposite of being the 4chan of the Bionicle community, considering last I checked, 4chan prided itself on being the most disgusting haven of bigotry on the internet.)

    • Upvote 5
  5. You're missing the point of this ranking; it's not about the product, it's about the company itself. It's about how people perceive the company. It doesn't matter if people need fancy watches. What matters is that, when asked about this watch company, people rated it favorably as a good company. The same goes for LEGO; the fact that they make toys isn't half as important as how and why they do so. There are plenty of fun toys, but LEGO goes the extra mile to ensure both customer satisfaction and ethical business practices. That has far more to do with their ranking than whether their product is unique or more useful than a fancy watch or whatever.

    • Upvote 3
  6. Are those magnet elements still in use? Brickset's inventory system suggests the magnet elements haven't been used in almost a decade, which suggests to me they might be retired. Considering their importance to this project, that seems like a barrier to approval.

     

    It's very clever, and I'd be happy to see it get approved, but I'm not optimistic.

  7. This series has had skeleton-themed hotrods, snake helicopters, and a pirate genie, all in the same mishmash universe, and all of you are acting like making the ninja highschoolers is the most ridiculous thing this movie could have done.

     

    Granted, I don't follow Ninjago, and don't currently plan to, so perhaps it's just that I'm less emotionally invested in this movie. It just seems silly to me to already say you're going to hate this movie just because they took indeterminately-aged characters and put them in a high school setting.

    • Upvote 2
  8.  

    The Lego website and its content was at its best in the mid-2000s.

    This is the single most true post you will ever find on the internet.

     

    What I wouldn't give to go back to the good old days. Before social media, before smartphones. Back when kids played with toys instead of tablets, and when people actually talked to each other instead of texting.

     

    Where did everything go so wrong?

     

     

    Me, personally, I miss the good ol' days before your good ol' days, when time for leisure was short, because we were busy hunting and gathering our food. Kids these days are so lazy. None of 'em even knows how to properly drive a mammoth off a cliff with fire, I tell you what.

    • Upvote 10
  9. Are you not seeing this original 96 version of the website? Clearly that's when it was at its best. I mean just LOOK at those gifs. I can play that HTML pirate game all day!

     

    signoff.png

     

    Oh man, I just noticed the game. It's really a thrill, especially the part where I went to an unarchived square and broke it.

  10. Yes and at least the first three years of bionicle had more character development, more characters, better sets and creatures and it really felt like a bionicle world

     

    >more character development

     

    ...where? where in the first three years of Bionicle did any of the Toa get more character development than one-dimensional personality traits? even in the books released in 2003, you could usually boil the Toa down to one or two key traits each, with little nuance or complexity to them.

     

    >more characters

     

    ...so? the mark of a good story isn't how many characters it can shove down your throat, it's how it uses them. 2001: A Space Odyssey has fewer named characters than Foodfight! yet I have never seen people hold up the latter as superior based on character count.

     

    >better sets

     

    this is subjective, and in some ways I do prefer the original Mata aesthetically (mostly for their iconic, basic masks, as contrasted by the overwrought messes we got in later years), but honestly, I loved last year's sets, and all of the ways I've been let down by this year's sets were ways in which they stepped back to the sins of G1's designs.

     

    >really felt like a bionicle world

     

    you know why it did? because it was what set the standards for what a bionicle world would feel like. of course G1 would feel like a bionicle world. The first Ace Attorney game feels like an Ace Attorney game. A New Hope feels like a Star Wars movie. there's no standards they have to reach to do that; they get it automatically by coming first.

     

    meanwhile, something new, it really has to fight fan nostalgia to prove itself worthy to exist in the same franchise. but you know what? the original bionicle cycled through so many different tones and aesthetics, i've found, looking back, that i can't pin down what makes a bionicle world. taken as a whole, the world of bionicle g1 is a lot of things. it's mysterious islands, it's metropolises, it's gangsters, it's crime syndicates, it's just all kinds of things mishmashed together as time went on.

     

    so when asking "does bionicle g2 feel like a bionicle world?" i go back to the basics. i go back to what defined the bionicle world for me: 2001, the origins of the bionicle world. Robotic people and creatures on a mysterious island landscape, hunting for masks of power, ancient artifacts that will augment their strength, fighting against the evil force of darkness, Makuta.

     

    If you ask me, this feels more like a Bionicle world than Voya Nui did.

    • Upvote 2
  11. It is important to note that G1 also had a mask hunt in its second year, with the exact same reasoning: new forms, new masks.

     

    In fact, if you're willing to loosen the definition just a smidge, there were three mask hunts in the first two years of Bionicle; the Toa also had to collect the Krana to reach the Bahrag.

     

    Hunting artifacts is a key aspect of the fantasy genre Bionicle gets most of its storytelling tropes from. It certainly never really stopped being a part of G1.

    • Upvote 1
  12. Comes across as hot-headed to me; he's saying "this is getting boring" out of frustration, not an innate desire for fun.

     

    That said, when you only have room for him to say five things, and most of it needs to be exposition/promotion, it's a little difficult to show character traits as well as you otherwise could.

    • Upvote 5
  13. I knew I wasn't going to like the look of Destroyer's back...

     

    Hard to judge many of these accurately due to the usual spotty Toy Fair posing, but I'm still tentatively interested in Lava Beast.

     

    Storm Beast's function seems interesting, and explains some of the issues I had with it before. If they're for the sake of a function, I'm willing to give them a bit of slack. Still not liking the arms, though.

     

    Quake beast, well... I'm willing to wait and see it not in Toy Fair posing, but while the function seems interesting, I just don't think I like the look of the result.

     

    Ekimu's just kind of... there. Sure, special mask and all, but he's just... humanoid. Ho hum.

  14. Of the summer sets, I honestly am looking forward to Lava Beast most, because it's the one I'm least iffy on. The lower legs are a bit plain and bony, and I'm not sure I like how any of the heads have been done, but overall it seems solid.

     

    The others, ehhh... Ekimu is rather plain, though the trans mask of creation seems interesting. Storm Beast and Quake Beast both seem rather... slapdash? Not severely, but enough that I'm not a fan of them. They're just... not very attractive. In particular, I have no idea what's going on with Quake Beast's right shoulder, but it... doesn't look good.

     

    Umarak the Destroyer is... big, that's for sure. I'm not a fan of the lower legs, which have a similar issue to his Hunter form in that they just feel very out of place. Rectangular and technic-y alongside mostly CCBS aesthetic. It feels off to me. He also has Axonn's hand proportions, which I'm not sure I like. They look rather gappy and off to me, though maybe I need to see them in person. And while I appreciate what they're trying to do with the mask, those horns just... aren't doing it for me. If they could have made the technic bits gold, perhaps, and/or made them thicker, it would look far better.

     

    And from what I can see from this front view, I'm not sure I'll like what I might see on the back.

×
×
  • Create New...