The original is definitely far superior, which is a real shame, because the second could really have been just as good. I've always felt that the fatal flaw was changing the gameplay style from the first-person to third-person view. The original was so immersive and beautiful, and playing it really made you feel like you were in Mata Nui, whereas in the MNOG II you just feel like you're looking at Mata Nui, rather than being a part of it. Not to mention that the way they implemented the new perspective, you have to wait for your character to travel across the screen, making it so much slower and very mind-numbing, only made worse by the game involving loads and loads of travelling for little errands. It really is sad, because the second game looked like a higher-budget production yet they missed the key elements that made the original so powerful. (Okay that's it I'm done crying about how much I love the MNOG)