Don't mistake our criticisms for old habits dying hard.
I'm not a grouchy old veteran who's opposed to anything new. I'm just a player who's been a member of this forum for five years. I've seen RPGs come and go, and I've gotten to know what works and what doesn't. Nobody here is trying to stifle your creativity. We're just trying to test the viability of your ideas.
If you look several pages back, you can see the conversations that sprang up around Bionifight. Many members were adamant that such a game wouldn't work. Some were sure it would be a hit. Regardless, everyone threw their criticisms at it, because it's only by addressing its weak points that an RPG will improve. The hosts defended their idea, took a lot of advice, discarded some, and ended up making a popular game.
Your RPG might work. However, I'm doubtful, simply because I know the players here and I know what they tend to like. That doubt isn't a personal attack on you or your ideas; it's just my opinion. You can take it or leave it, but like everyone here, my goal isn't to see you get shut down. It's to see your idea become the best it can be.
I'll reply to some of your points tomorrow. I just wanted to put this up because I want to make sure we keep a good atmosphere in here. We're all on the same team.