Jump to content

Rivalry


Simulacrum

Recommended Posts

Fuming, I grabbed the other sword from where it laid, by fingers wrapping around it’s handle with ease.

This should be 'my' fingers. This is the only spelling mistake I could find.Anyway, I really enjoyed this story. I liked how detailed you were in describing the fight, like with Vultraz spinning his sword in his hand before he tried to make a killing blow. His taunting of Mazeka (i'm assuming that is who the speaker is. :P), with him temptimg the Ko-Matoran to try to kill him, was very neat and thoughtout. If I had only one nitpick about this story, it would be that it didn't show who won the fight between these two. I kind of see the battle between Mazeka and Vultraz as the focus of the story, but I would've liked to see a victor at the end of it. That's just me, though. I still thought this was a good story. http://www.bzpower.com/board/public/style_emoticons/default/cool.png

Everyone is one choice away from being the bad guy in another person's story.


 


pc0lX6T.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ohh man. You were right, Darkon. This is great. the end is pure genius, the premise works really well, and even though it's relatively short, it's still excellent. Well done. Your imagery and description are amazing: I particularly love your description of Vultraz's voice, "like fingernails across a chalkboard." It's too perfect. And that the last sentence is simply sublime. If there's one thing I'd criticize, it's this passage.

He started to say before I swung both swords in a downward stroke at him. Vultraz cursed in a surprised, almost happy fashion. “Perhaps I was wrong. Maybe you are a fighter.” He said as he lunged forward and ripped his blade from my grasp before I could stop him.

I have a couple of problems. first, it's not entirely clear what's happening. Did Vultraz dodge? Did he back up? How did he avoid the Narrator's [i'm assuming it's Mazeka?] downward slash?The other thing is really minor: the period after "fighter" should be a comma, and the "He" shouldn't be capitalized. It flows better that way.Overall, great work. If you can't tell already, I love it. Well done!

.

 

{Z}

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello, Lord Darkon, here is your official SSCC review. I must say, after reading "Blood on the Sand" not too long ago, I was a little excited about being assigned one of your stories. The dynamic that was created between Mazeka and Vultraz, despite coming along so late in the Bionicle storyline, always felt like the endless battle of good and evil between Batman and the Joker. These two entities are, as Matoran, pretty normal. But they are everything the other despises, not to mention that Vultraz has killed individuals that Mazeka cared about. Sure, the hole in my theory is that, unlike Batman, Mazeka is willing to kill, so it's not a perfect comparison. Moving on…In this little glimpse into the eternal (well eternal until Vultraz is kept in that universe where the white armored Teridax is from) battle between two deadly Matoran, I only ran across a single spelling issue and (possibly) a grammar one.

“Don’t you ever learn?” He asked,

Typically, the first word to follow an ending quotation mark is not capitalized, but you ignored that through your entire story. Consistency is key in writing, at which point some of the worst mistakes are merely called style. So I can overlook this, unless it was all unintentional.

I’ve killed love ones of yours.

I've killed loved ones of yours.As a title, I'm a little confused on what you meant by "Rivalry." The Google definition reads: Competition for the same objective or for superiority in the same field. Vultraz seems to be more of a nemesis than a rival to Mazeka, and even adversary would be an appropriate term.Giving credit where it's due though, you can certainly set the stage for a fight. If "Blood on the Sand" taught me anything, you are excellent at writing a battle scene. Because in the heat of battle, every little exertion, every step, can be critical to victory. You seem to be very aware of this, and make a point of vividly describing the precise actions of these two opponents. The tension is there and you really lead up to what could be an incredible finish.And then…it doesn't come. That last sentence unraveled everything for me. Let me level with you for a second here. Mazeka and Vultraz have an endless battle dynamic to them, as I said earlier, and there's no real way to end that. I was even disappointed when Greg just had Vultraz retained in another dimension, but this just feels like I've been shortchanged. And in a way, I feel like you've shortchanged yourself as a writer. "Rivalry" concludes with no resolution whatsoever and unlike certain stories that leave you wondering or wrap up on a cliffhanger, this seems lazy.Again, let me stress that I was very enthralled by the duel between Mazeka and Vultraz, the ending just failed to resonate with me, clearly brought on by the way you executed the finale. There's something more compelling about two enemies eventually parting ways, not giving a roundabout explanation of how much fight they have in them. It needs that touch of "You haven't seen the last of me!" or, to reference one of my favorite childhood shows, "I'll get you next time, Gadget!" Looking at the responses, there is a consensus that your ending was "perfect," "sublime," and "pure genius." Perhaps I'm missing something, but for now, I stand by my examination. "Rivalry" is a heated battle with strong dialogue and a conclusion that leaves something to be desired. Keep at it, Lord Darkon.-Ced
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you for your review, which was very insightful. When I first wrote this story, I couldn't decide on what to name it, so I choose something random. As you can tell, not a intelligent or thought-out idea. Your insight on the end was very interesting, and as I re-read it, I saw everything you said. I'm now beginning to dislike it, but I'll keep it, because I really dislike changing large parts of my story. Thank you for pointing that out, though. I'll be sure to consider that the next time I write. Also, I had no idea that after an quotation it remains uncapitalized.Thank you for your time and thoughts!

pNNgXax.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Error fixed. Anyway, thanks for the review! I thought that the ending would tease readers that way, leaving them to decide how it all ends... Apparently, it worked. :P

Well, it's obvious that neither of them dies, because they both appear later on in the story. But still, awesome job! I really loved this. The ending was kinda abrupt, though. XD
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...