Okay, I've read the books and I think they're great, but some of the things don't fit the storyline. For example, instead of getting their Golden Kanohi at the Suvas, the Toa go to Kini-Nui and place their masks on statues of themselves. After that's done, the Golden Kanohi appear on the statues. Also, it appears that the Toa never battle Makuta after the Shadow Toa. Please post your opinion.

Well though the Golden Masks thing is inaccurate, GregF gave an explanation as to why the battle with Makuta wasn't in the books. He said that everything was tied together. The comics, the online game and updates, the books, and the movie. You have to get it all to know the whole story. And usually stuff that appears in comics doesn't appear onilne. And vise-versa. And anything online won't appear in the comics or the books. So since the battle with Makuta was online, it wasn't in the book.

KS

Well i think it is good to show all the different sides of the bionicle storyline. Even if it is different to the comics or online, you still get the general idea!

There are quite a bit of inaccuracies.

1) The description of the Suvas

2) The account of the Golden masks

3) Lewa's Le-koronan treespeak

4) Before the renaming ceremony they misnamed Huki.

It's almost as if C. A. Hapka didn't even research all of the medias. It seems like they were based completly on the comics.

QUOTE (Kopaka, Bringer of Cold Justice @ Aug 25 2003, 06:02 PM)

3) Lewa's Le-koronan treespeak

Actually that really isn't an inaccuracy. According to GregF they always meant to give him that kind of talk, but they never actually put it in. He also said he talks like that in the movie. At least that is what I heard.

KS

QUOTE (Kopaka, Bringer of Cold Justice @ Aug 25 2003, 03:02 PM)

There are quite a bit of inaccuracies. 1) The description of the Suvas 2) The account of the Golden masks 3) Lewa's Le-koronan treespeak 4) Before the renaming ceremony they misnamed Huki. It's almost as if C. A. Hapka didn't even research all of the medias. It seems like they were based completly on the comics.

(About your sig: be a Onua fan like me! )

I think it adds depth to the story to have all these different accounts. Also, it gets more people to buy the books! It's the truth!

Well, sometimes the storyline has small inaccuracies. In every story. No one's perfect. Heck, sometimes I make errors in chronology in my stories. Since most of them are set in the future, and characters occasionally refer to the past, I have to be extra carefull about timelines. But sometimes they get mixed up. It happens.

The Wanderer

I think they just do things to fit the storey line. but neather methed is confirmed

QUOTE (The Wanderer @ Aug 25 2003, 09:36 PM)

Well, sometimes the storyline has small inaccuracies. In every story. No one's perfect. Heck, sometimes I make errors in chronology in my stories. Since most of them are set in the future, and characters occasionally refer to the past, I have to be extra carefull about timelines. But sometimes they get mixed up. It happens. The Wanderer

Me too. My Epic (see sig) Also take place in the future. I am trying to finish it before the MOL. Just incase something happens that doesn't take place in my story. But you are right. I have seen many stories, books, and even shows that get mixed up. It may be little, but it is still there.

KS

I have not read the books yet but i think that Maybe they were ideas that were going to be used but descided not to!

I don't have the books, but the same thing hapenns in mnolg, Lewa recieves his golden kanohi at his suva, then all the toa go to kini-nui and recieve the golden kanohi, and lewa does it again