Undertale, but I'd also rank Hard West pretty highly. I mean, what's not to love about Weird West that plays like XCOM but rapidly goes in other directions with the basics?

For games that came out in 2015, I'd have to say Undertale.

If I could pick anything I played this year, I would of course choose Virtue's Last Reward.

I realize that this is a pretty common answer, but I really enjoyed Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain. Even though I'm still playing through it, the gameplay thus far is outstanding.

Undertale is a close second though obvi, what an amazing game

Pretend I put spooktune in my comment

The answer is, objectively, The Witcher 3

*Snaps fingers*

Heroes of the Storm, by virtue of the fact that its the only game I invested any money in last year that I'm still playing in 2016. Destiny grew tiring after about two months and my PS4 is about to be sold, and the Wii U has been collecting dust (will be getting Splatoon eventually though). As for PC gaming, the final Starcraft II campaign has been sitting at 95 percent completion since I bought it in November, and I've finally moved on from Team Fortress 2 and Valve in general.

That Heroes of the Storm though... I never thought I would enjoy a game in a genre that is almost invariably noob-slaying and unbearably toxic,, but Blizzard basically fixed everything utterly wrong with MOBAs, including adding a versus AI mode that turns it into a relaxing co-op game rather than a rage-inducing competitive clusterfudge (which you can still participate in as well, if you're interested in that kind of stuff). So here's to another year of buying playable characters with free in-game currency (and yes, occasionally with real money, because I'm a terrible person).

Sakura Clicker

why VGA give Rocket League Best Indie Game and MGSV Best Soundtrack I don't understand??? I think the judges just didn't really know anything about Undertale at all????

at least they gave Splatoon Best Shooter and Best Multiplayer... Oddly enough, those are really the only two new games I got for this year, besides Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate. 

So yeah, by virtue of not really purchasing any games, I really super liked MH4U, Undertale, and Splatoon. 

I'd say Bloodborne. Really managed to take Lovecraftian horror in a new creative direction. I'm a sucker for indescribable, unspeakable, incomprehensible aliens. So I'd say Bloodborne is my GOTY for 2015

Majora's Mask 3D is just a remake, so... Undertale.  And Temmie Village.

Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate or Splatoon.