blogs_blog_1019

Which is why I rarely review MOCs. Another thing I've noticed is that good MOCs will often get less posts because there's less to criticize.

 

[img=http://www.majhost.com/gallery/TalonX/randomstuff/blogapproval01.png]

 

 

~D

Yeah, I don't review as much I used to, either. Now that you mention it, you might be on to something. But DV's and Roa's MOCs kinda work against this. Thanks for the seal!

 

-K-

Which is why I rarely review MOCs. Another thing I've noticed is that good MOCs will often get less posts because there's less to criticize.

 

[img=http://www.majhost.com/gallery/TalonX/randomstuff/blogapproval01.png]

 

 

~D

 

So I'm not the only one who noticed that.

 

I've realized that the art of review has almost died out. You, Kopakalaka are one of the few ones who still do this. You always give me a very detailed review so I can get better at my weak points.

 

I've also notice that this is the reason why the same people get into the finals and semifinals. Look at DV, he's been here long enough to hear from others what's good and bad. That why his MOCs rule.

 

We are from the generation that still gave full reviews, so we gained experience from out mistakes. That's what made most of us good MOCers.

 

Now most people are post hungry and want to add three or four words, to get too there 1,000 posts.

 

That's not always a bad thing though. The less people get better, the easier it is to get to those finals.

 

Good statement. I think you deserve this: Retro Award

I never considered it an art, but I guess it kinda is. I try to make my reviews worthwhile.

 

Yup

 

High five oldster!

 

Yeah. What's the big deal with post counts anyway? I mean, Hapori Tohu has 36 posts, and he's one of the most respected members on BZPower.

 

Lol

 

*Gasp* The Retro Gemma! *Faints*

 

-K-

Yes, these sort of reveiws drive me crazy.

Number ratings make me overreact.

 

So you know what I do?

I write nice long reviews, for MOCs that deserve them.

Here are a few MOCs I took the time to do a review on.

 

1. 2. 3.

 

NOTE: THESE TOPICS ARE DEAD don't post in them. Okay?

 

Be interested to know what people think of these, and if there is another person out there that does these thing, PLEASE let me know!

 

-Brickeens-

 

Crazy's a bad thing? Oops.... Number reviews *Shudders* Just kidding .

 

Not bad reviews. I don't see much criticism, though. Of course, you might've had a different view of the MOCs then, than I do now.

 

-K-

 

That's because I couldn't find much to criticise.

I completely agree with you.

And that would be the reason why you, Draxon, BD, Anathame.... (etc.) Are all good MOCists. Because they would get good quality reveiws.

 

Now if only I could get myself some of those kind of reviews. I only get about 1, 2, maybe 3 if I'm lucky, good quality reveiws in my MOC topics.

 

))Z((

I try to cast a good review each time I reply to a new MoC topic. The way I see it what goes around should eventually come around, right? Sometime?

Ditto! I've seen countless posts in Moc topics, obviously showing they just posted for a extra post, i.e. "Good job. 9/10.".

 

Another thing I've noticed is exactly what you said, about a lot members not giving very good advice to beginning MOCers, or just giving them simple reviews, and not giving them any constructive criticism. Ok, now I'm just repeating what you said.

 

Anyway, I agree. Tis' growing in the BBC.

 

 

 

-D-