As you probably know, I like being a critic helping out.

Sure, I'll be a judge.

I'll judge.

Hey, I was going to say this in the PM you sent me but I'll kill two birds with one stone so everyone else can hear this:

I don't mind judging, and I think this is a cool idea to do with friends, but I hope you are aware this is sort of like what someone did once with this art voting, to see who was "the best". I'm not very fond of this, because every writer has their own style. You could judge a story on the plot, or the writing talent, or the characterization...it's very hard to judge this sort of stuff, because when someone is good in one thing, another person may be better in another.

This is more like a contest, so that's okay, I just wanted to state that.

Can I be one of the ones going against you?

If not, I'll be a judge if you want.

Hey, I was going to say this in the PM you sent me but I'll kill two birds with one stone so everyone else can hear this:

 

I don't mind judging, and I think this is a cool idea to do with friends, but I hope you are aware this is sort of like what someone did once with this art voting, to see who was "the best". I'm not very fond of this, because every writer has their own style. You could judge a story on the plot, or the writing talent, or the characterization...it's very hard to judge this sort of stuff, because when someone is good in one thing, another person may be better in another.

 

This is more like a contest, so that's okay, I just wanted to state that.

Lady K totally has to be a judge. Not just because I know she's a great reviewer, but look at that post! She's obviously very smart!

BTW, awesome title, NM. Very epic. B)

And in response to your post, Lady K, I'm not taking this as a serious "who's the best" sort of contest. Personally, I'm really proud of the story I wrote, and I don't really care if I win or not. To me, this is all done in fun, so ... yeah. This is just a friendly rivalry thing for me.

~Eyru~

Let me go on the list of judges! I´m in!

Hey, I was going to say this in the PM you sent me but I'll kill two birds with one stone so everyone else can hear this:

 

I don't mind judging, and I think this is a cool idea to do with friends, but I hope you are aware this is sort of like what someone did once with this art voting, to see who was "the best". I'm not very fond of this, because every writer has their own style. You could judge a story on the plot, or the writing talent, or the characterization...it's very hard to judge this sort of stuff, because when someone is good in one thing, another person may be better in another.

 

This is more like a contest, so that's okay, I just wanted to state that.

Lady K totally has to be a judge. Not just because I know she's a great reviewer, but look at that post! She's obviously very smart!

 

BTW, awesome title, NM. Very epic. B)

 

And in response to your post, Lady K, I'm not taking this as a serious "who's the best" sort of contest. Personally, I'm really proud of the story I wrote, and I don't really care if I win or not. To me, this is all done in fun, so ... yeah. This is just a friendly rivalry thing for me.

 

~Eyru~

Everyone participating knows and appreciate each other's skill, it's a friendly thing.

-Nuju Metru

Take this approval seal to go along woth the other one.

Take this approval seal to go along woth the other one.

 

Thanks!

I'm one of those Titans, right?

Anyway, I might get this up today like I promised, but since I have obligations that must be fulfilled tonight, I may not until tomorrow.

-Inferna, Guardian Mistress

I'm one of those Titans, right?

 

Anyway, I might get this up today like I promised, but since I have obligations that must be fulfilled tonight, I may not until tomorrow.

 

-Inferna, Guardian Mistress

Yes, you are.

Okay, I look forward to it.

Okay, I'd just like to confirm I'll be a judge for you, thanks for understanding my point earlier guys.

Well, I'm very satisfied to see that this "rivalry" has been bringing out a lot of good writing from many people... The contestants have been putting forth their best.

-Nuju Metru

I'm not trying to revive old blog entries, but did we ever finish this? Like, with the judging and everything? I can't even remember if everyone posted their stories...

I'm not trying to revive old blog entries, but did we ever finish this? Like, with the judging and everything? I can't even remember if everyone posted their stories...

I don't think everyone who signed on ended up writing one... but it doesn't matter too much, you know? We all did a good job, and all came to appreciate each other's talents. That's what matters, IMO.