Just to be clear. He IS in his Na'vi avatar right? You called him a crippled Marine in the second sentence, so it's a little confusing(I know he was in the film, but, ya know...).

I vote for Jake Sully. He's taller, faster and stronger.

Mike Myers only has a knife.

Yeah, he's using the avatar. I just blithered badly.

Alas, the random number gods were cruel this round, but there is one match up I refuse to allow to not happen.

Jake. If only because that's the only person I've seen in action, of the two. =P haven't watched the other set of movies, at least not yet.

Myers.

He builds suspense as he lumbers forward, even though you could've sworn he was an hour behind you.

Plus, with the way Myers drives, I think he'd kill just about anything. (Yes, it's that bad).

Sully all the way!

Myers. Horror villains never go down, anyway.

Jake.