-
Posts
1,231 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Events
Blogs
Store
Raffles
Posts posted by Boidoh
-
-
See the thing is, I learnt to stop asking those stuff on BZP. The only exception was my 'Vezok Bull Rider' topic. When I first returned back to BZP in July, I asked about if the Toa Nuva are in their Karda Nui forms, a question which could be CANONICALLY answered by Greg rather than hearing non canon fan theories. After I found out about LMB I knew I would never have to go through what seemed to be a never ending back and forth
then Lehvak-Kal came.In fact, I'll ask Greg right now what that Rahi was.Also, do you really think that after spending ALL SUMMER on BS01 editing, making that MLNBC walkthrough, and intensely reading every page, that I wouldn't know that they were moons? It came as a shock to me too, but if Greg says the word, it is so.
Edit: Physics are physics, Greg answers are Greg answers. Greg does what he wants because he has a Masters Degree in comicbook science, not real science.
And no. I don't know what he was thinking. I asked that question as more of a clarification question, to see if the moon had a moon. I don't know about him... He says it was always like that... Nothing you can do really, just ask on LMB and hope for the best. But really isn't it being like this a LOT cooler?
And where did AM's moon come from? I know it exists but what was the origin of it? A LMB post? The sky in MoL?
All I can find is a one liner from MNOGII.
- 1
-
Subject Rejection Reason Posted
Re: Chat with Greg Farshtey
LEGO General
Was Reysa revived? - Killed by a tentacled monster
Your post is considered inappropriate. Please review the community guidelines for more information.
What!?
I was curious to see if a moon could have a moon, WEEKS AGO. Thats why.
Boidoh wrote:
ScribeGT6817 wrote:
Boidoh wrote:
A while back I asked you if Bota/Aqua Magna revolved around Bara Magna and you said no. Does this mean that they had their own orbit around Solis Magna?
Yes
Was it always this way? Did it at one point orbit Bara Magna but then broke off from its orbit and began orbit around Solis Magna?
To my knowledge, it was always this way, but it's not something the story team ever discussed.
- 2
-
As I said in my edited post, Greg has denied your simple Math with Lehvak-Kal before, calling simple math physics.
Logic doesn't make progress, days of interrogation does. With Greg anyways.
- 1
-
Or real life physics don't apply... And isn't your sun a bit too tiny?
Also, when I told Greg Yalda's stance on how Lehvak-Kal still SHOULD be in orbit, about how simple inertia shouldn't rip him out and what not, Greg gave the usual physics answer. Whatever is possible in comics is possible in BIONICLE.
And how am I trying to trick forgetful authors? I had no motive of that. In fact, weeks ago when I asked the question, I WANTED them as moons, then Greg let me down. I wanted the moon to have a moon. I thought it would be cool...
-
Once I was curious if the moons had moons, then Greg told me that they didn't orbit BM.
Then this happened.
On this case it is not really extorting answers. With Lehvak-Kal, that was days of torture, with this Greg simply answered ONE question from me without elaborating more. AND, it was good as confirmed weeks ago when I asked Greg if BM and AM orbited BM. So I don't see how this can be compared to what I did with Lehvak-Kal.
Boidoh wrote:
A while back I asked you if Bota/Aqua Magna revolved around Bara Magna and you said no. Does this mean that they had their own orbit around Solis Magna?YesSee? Simple.I already made some follow up questions from before this extorted into a big argument asking him if they are only CALLED moons such as Venus being called the Morning Star.I guess I'll ask that, but one question. The way you say 'clear my reputation', does this mean that on BZP and BS01 I'm practically hated for ruining all they thought they knew about BIONICLE? -
They may be close in whatever picture you saw, but if Teridax takes about a day or so to travel from Aqua Magna to Bara Magna, it sure isn't close. Plus, it might just be that they formed their orbit around Solis Magna very close to the orbit of Bara Magna's.
2. It also said planet.
-
If you never read the books you would have no idea what 2006 was about... Same goes for 2007.
-
I felt like the comics never really told the story well and were just there for no reason.
I read all the 2006 comics and it was no where as good as the books.
If you only went off of the comics, you would never understand the full story of the year.
-
A life sized Great Spirit Robot, with two Glatorian as drivers.
- 1
-
The comics were great and felt very BIONICLE.
The books by Hapka felt very odd. I was reading them and it just didn't feel interesting, it didn't feel like Greg.
We NEED Greg.
- 1
-
Stars.
-
No they don't.
If I recall in the Mata Nui saga, it calls Aqua Magna the 'ocean world'.
Real life physics don't apply in BIONICLE.
Wasn't that just some fan theory? He said it makes sense. I could say the Big Bang Theory makes sense, but it still may not be true.
No it isn't.
Yes it does.
-
Everyone said I was crazy, they said I was mad, INSANE; just like my idol Vezon.
BUT I KNEW!
-
His destiny was confirmed to have played a crucial role in a civil war between the Great Beings...
- 1
-
It went wrong in the second half of 2010, when HF came.
-
I got a migraine listening to that.
tldr Go to shop.lego.com for yourself.
- 3
-
i chose to try to take my old toa mata tahu stars and my hero factory collection can actually burn and i forgot y moc
... Yeah in the event of a house fire, I think I have more important things to save than my LEGO collection. Like my laptop, back up drive, sentimental items, etc.
I agree wholeheartedly .
But just for fun's sake, I would take my Toa Metru Vakama. He was my third Bionicle figure purchased, and the only one of the top three that isn't missing pieces/contain broken pieces.
I would grab my 01 Tahu Mata set. It was one of the two Bionicle sets I first got, and even though the other one (Lewa) is cool, I like Tahu a little more.
Why nab Toa of Fire who are obviously resistant to it?
- 2
-
LEGO Technic Rough Terrain Crane
I broke it apart for the pieces for my BIONICLEs eventually though, I ran out of red pins.
-
Yeah I know it said that, but this bull thing was brown, and cool looking. It kinda looked like an Ash Bear.
- 1
-
I remember it from the LMB.
Also, Venus is called the Morning/Evening star, and it's a planet.
I'll re-ask Greg.
I'll also try to find the old quotes.
HERE IS IT!
NUMBER ELEVEN!
-
"That part of Aqua Magna was pointed away from Bara Magna, into a locked orbit like our moon."
Aqua and Bota Magna did not rotate around Bara Magna, so they are not moons, they had their own orbit around Solis Magna. They are their own planet.
I hate how stuff like the Mata Nui Saga keeps calling them moons.
-
I was just reading Power Play and it described a room where you could learn to ride on wild rahi, or something like that. I immediately remembered the Piraka ad where Vezok was riding a bull looking thing.
THE BEAST, FROM BIONICLE.
So what was interesting was that it seems to be wearing a scarred looking Hau. What rahi is it?
- 2
-
He describes it as the 'biggest secret of all time' but, eh.
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gzSv_fNgTLs&list=UUHbcwfjBn2P_6GHw5ottF5A
1:47:00
Is it the thing about some Revolution character and some Turaga looking dude?
Rumor: Bionicle's return in 2015
in Bionicle Discussion
Posted
What do you have against Greg?