If you saw...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Shout at him to become Goku Black.

If pre-mutation Krika turned out to be the herald of the Mask of Light, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would think that would be an interesting character development for Krika and would be excited to see what he did with such a title.

 

If Vakama had gave in to his Hordika side and stayed that way, you would've...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Probably be upset, since I kind of like Vakama, but retain hope that perhaps someday he'd be able to be redeemed.

This one is kind of silly, but... If Romance were a canon BIONICLE elemental power, you would...

[Wiriamu]

Be disgusted-the whole Cupid effect has long struck me as being stupid at best, fairly disturbing at worst.

 

If you found yourself in a full on mirror Bionicle universe (Toa are evil and Makuta are/is good-depending on generation-and so forth, not just evil Toa or good Makuta) you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Cry and hope to get out of there soon.

If BIONICLE went through a Star Wars-like canon reshuffle, where only the set stories and none of the expanded stuff were canon, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would be glad that the Red Star being able to revive beings would be removed from canon because of it. 

 

If Makuta starred in a horror movie, you would..

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Be afraid.  Be very afraid.

If LEGO released an official Toa of Iron set, whether in G1 or G2, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would hope it would have a new Kanohi Mask design.

 

If Tahu had become corrupted from wearing the Mask of Ultimate Power, you would've...

Edited December 22, 2016 by Toa Smoke Monster

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Hope that it wouldn't end up like the Vakama betrayal part of Web of Shadows.

If Matau had been the one to betray the Toa Hordika, like Greg had planned, you would...

[Wiriamu]

Have my mind blown, as it would turn his prankster personality into a much more intense character trait stemming either from a penitent desire or the need to distance himself from his guilt-inspired depression.

 

If Papu and Rangi had made it into the story...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would still have no idea who they were.

 

If Tahu had died at the end of the Gen 1 story, you would've...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Cried.  Then hoped that someone worthy enough would take his place.

If Gorast weren't a part of the Karda Nui story arc, you would...

[Wiriamu]

Hope that another female Makuta took her place.

 

If Hero Factory and Bionicle G2 had run concurrently.

Edited December 27, 2016 by Wiriamu

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I still would've just bought Gen 2 Bionicle sets, as Hero Factory never really got my interest.

 

If Kulta had been an actual threat to Ekimu and the Toa, you would've...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Been very happy.  Kulta always seemed like a very cool villain, so it'd be great if the fight between him and the Toa was cool, too.

If the G2 Toa had been overwhelmed by Skull Warriors, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would hope they would ask the Protectors to help fight against them. Seeing them team up in a battle would've been really cool.

 

If you could give Skull Slicer a canon name, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Call him Steve.

If BIONICLE were adapted into a Big Bang Theory-like sitcom, you would...

[Wiriamu]

Hope they introduced more female characters without making them dumb.

 

If Lego went bankrupt

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Cry deeply.

If BIONICLE had movies filling in the gaps between Web of Shadows and The Legend Reborn, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would be interested in seeing how a movie dealing with the 2007 story with be handled.

 

If Mata Nui had never woken up, you would've...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Welcomed our new Makuta overlord.

If BIONICLE G3 turned out to be worse than BIONICLE G2, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would look forward to the entertainment I would get from watching the Internet tear it apart for being bad.

 

If someone made a Hairspray movie but replaced all the characters with one from Bionicle, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Watch it repeatedly.

If it was revealed that there was a secret sect of monks in the Matoran Universe that didn't believe in Mata Nui, you would...

[Wiriamu]

Enjoy their reaction at the conclusion of the 2008 storyline and Bara Magna story.

 

If Velika had been revealed as Black Phantom's mysterious boss/the creator of the Brains in Hero Factory...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Whoa.

If the Brotherhood of Makuta attempted to recruit you into their ranks, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would join them. Until I found a way to take them out, that is. 

 

If Tom Cruise was going to star in a future Bionicle movie, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Not watch it.  Tom Cruise does not deserve my attention.

If BIONICLE had its own version of the Joker, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would think he would go by another name: Vezon.

 

If you had the materials to build a Matoran, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Build a Po-Matoran.  His name would be Yanly, and we'd have lots of fun together.

If Magic was a canon BIONICLE element, you would...

[Wiriamu]

Say that's pretty cheap, since it would pretty much much encompass all Elemental and mask powers.

 

If the G1 gender ratio had been reversed...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I wouldn't have cared as long as the characters themselves were still cool and interesting.

 

If a Toa of Iron decided to destroy you house, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Make him build me a new one.

If a mod decided to close this topic, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would be saddened, as I like this topic.

 

If Makuta challenged you to a game of chess, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Win, obviously.

If Toa could go through Super Saiyan-like transformations, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would think that it would become overused and overshadow other characters who didn't possess such an ability.

 

If Gali used her powers to flood your house, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Be glad that I finally have that indoor swimming pool.

If Gorast hit you with her Mask of Disruption, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would be disrupted.

 

If you could give Sidorak one piece of advice, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Tell him that Darth Vader already has a cool breathing mask and that Sidorak should find something else.

If the Karda Nui Makuta asked you to go with them on a campout, you would...

[Toa Smoke Monster]

I would tell them that I don't do camp outs, and go away to play more video games.

 

If you found a Mask of Water Breathing on the beach one day, you would...

[Resentful Knight Endolf]

Swim for as long as I want.

If there was a Mask of Filtration, which basically served as a super-powered gas mask, you would...