I would have to agree with you, Pirates 3 was amazing. (Of course anything with Johnny Depp in it is amazing, he is an amazing actor) I usually go on the opinions of the critics but I totally disagree on their judgement on this one. I would have to say the length got to them. I will hopefully watch it out again. I disagree with the critics on Spidey 3 as well, I didn't like it so much...