15 replies to this topic

[Ziko]

Well folks, this is it. Welcome to the final poll for Comics Contest #1: Get a Clue!
This poll will run until March 11 at 11:59 P.M. EDT. The results will be posted in a new topic in the Comics forum.
Because of a tie in one of the preliminary polls, we added a sixth entry to the final round. You may vote for one entry in this poll.

----------

1. At The End of the Tunnel

[page 1, page 2, page 3]

2. A Dark Deed

[page 1, page 2, page 3, page 4]

3. Mystery Theater

[page 1, page 2]

4. The Mystery of the Toa

[page 1, page 2, page 3, page 4, page 5, page 6, page 7]

5. City of Wretches

[page 1, page 2, page 3, page 4, page 5, page 6, page 7, page 8, page 9, page 10, page 11]

6. Lightkeepers

[page 1, page 2]

Edited by Pantophobia, Mar 09 2012 - 12:41 AM.

[Janaro]

I'm personally hoping that ADD or Mystery Theater win, because they showcase the spirit of the Comics forum best. And I don't even like Mystery Theater.

[an cool dude]

After reading all the entries, I felt the one I liked best was City of Wretches. It instilled me with the best feeling of mystery that also provided an amazing visual experience.

The other entries are very good, too, though. Best of luck to all!

[The Renegade Emperor]

City of Wretches.




----- Lord of the Rings -----

Titles: Dark Lord, Lord of Mordor, Lord of Gifts, Lord of Barad-Dûr, Lord of the Earth

[Sumiki]

I loved both City of Wretches and Lightkeepers, but City of Wretches won out. It's just too awesome.

[Tekulo the WindWriter]

I'm actually kinda sad to see that Corruption didn't make it this far (its story was my favorite among all of the entries).

A lot of good comics here. A comic isn't just story-driven nor does it rely on imagery; a good comic has a balance of script and visual aid in my opinion.
I'd have to say that the entry in this contest that is the most balanced in this respect is City of Wretches.

[Toa of Dancing]

In the end, for me, it was down to "City of Wretches" and "Lightkeepers." Both were exceedingly well drawn, but in the end the atmosphere and length of the former won me over.

[xon]

All of these entries were great, but "At the End of the Tunnel" was my favorite. It was very well drawn and well created in general.

-xon

[Roablin]

I had to vote for City of Wretches. I really liked Lightkeepers and the end of the tunnel, and those three were all good in different ways. But CoW won out because of length, and that wickedly awesome Hakann.

[Phyoohrii]

City of Wretches for me. Amazing drawing, really chilling feel. Really struck me when I first read it.

A really great final poll, all really exceptional entries. Good luck to all!

[Calvirick]

I personally would vote for Uncle K's if this was an art contest that specifically focused on pure ART!

But city of Wretches won me over because of how his story was written. I wish he would keep writing comics...

[Dallas Winston]

I personally would vote for Uncle K's if this was an art contest that specifically focused on pure ART!

But city of Wretches won me over because of how his story was written. I wish he would keep writing comics...

I love your avatar.

Anyway, yeah, voted City of Wretches.

-Teezy

[Legolover-361]

I think City of Wretches deserves victory. It has such a brilliant comic art style, and the plot provides welcome depth.

[The Novelist Called Nuile]

Mystery Theater is my single choice to win this thing. I feel it's the only comic that properly grasped the feel I was expecting from a submission for a mystery-themed comic contest. A Dark Deed was a close second, well-written, funny, excellent art--but, as a mystery, it didn't satisfy me, and art and jokes have to defer in this case to mystery quality of plot.

Sincerely, Nuile: Lunatic Wordsmith

[Kumata]

City of Wretches. The art was incredible.

[-Windrider-]

Thank you all for your votes! Look for the results topic tomorrow!