Sonic The Hedgehog

[Chibinuva]

I some how would like to see Silver playable and Shadow for episode 3. I am curious how his powers would work with that element. Shadow and Silver would be great add ons to playable characters and rivals against Sonic. In fact, I think Shadow and Silver should work together. Also if you seen the sprite videos on them before. Silver and Shadow are not like that.

That would be impossible, and if Sonic Team did that, I'm sure that they'd lose lots of Sonic fans. Shadow and Silver really aren't that popular anymore.And besides, Sonic 4 takes place right after Sonic 3 & Knuckles. Shadow wasn't around then, and Silver wasn't either. The only possible characters are Sonic, Tails, Amy, Metal Sonic, Eggman/Robotnik, and Knuckles. And Mighty.

I remember having this conversation (I think it was with you,) about why Shadow and Silver could be included. Silver is from the future, so he would have to time-travel just like he has in every other game. Simple. Shadow was created around 50 years ago, so he would've been around before Sonic. The only real issue is that would mess up the rest of the storyline assuming it takes place right after episode 1, unless they decide to pull an 06 and retcon the whole thing.

Sega seems to have retconned Silvers time travel with Generations,

he's with Sonic and co. at the ending.

 

However

It could simply be because they were all there to provide morale support for the Sonic's after they were saved, and after Time Eater was defeated they all went back to the party, and since everyone else was there Silver didn't leave until after the game ended. Not to mention even if 06 was retconned he still time-traveled in the Rivals games which weren't retconned and were canon.

[Makuta Matata]

I some how would like to see Silver playable and Shadow for episode 3. I am curious how his powers would work with that element. Shadow and Silver would be great add ons to playable characters and rivals against Sonic. In fact, I think Shadow and Silver should work together. Also if you seen the sprite videos on them before. Silver and Shadow are not like that.

That would be impossible, and if Sonic Team did that, I'm sure that they'd lose lots of Sonic fans. Shadow and Silver really aren't that popular anymore.And besides, Sonic 4 takes place right after Sonic 3 & Knuckles. Shadow wasn't around then, and Silver wasn't either. The only possible characters are Sonic, Tails, Amy, Metal Sonic, Eggman/Robotnik, and Knuckles. And Mighty.

I remember having this conversation (I think it was with you,) about why Shadow and Silver could be included. Silver is from the future, so he would have to time-travel just like he has in every other game. Simple. Shadow was created around 50 years ago, so he would've been around before Sonic. The only real issue is that would mess up the rest of the storyline assuming it takes place right after episode 1, unless they decide to pull an 06 and retcon the whole thing.

Sega seems to have retconned Silvers time travel with Generations,

he's with Sonic and co. at the ending.

 

However

It could simply be because they were all there to provide morale support for the Sonic's after they were saved, and after Time Eater was defeated they all went back to the party, and since everyone else was there Silver didn't leave until after the game ended. Not to mention even if 06 was retconned he still time-traveled in the Rivals games which weren't retconned and were canon.

 

Guys, the answer is painfully obvious. Silver is in Generations because

Sonic Team said so.

[Creep Of The Deep]

Sonic Colours > Sonic GenerationsThere, I said it.I really love Windly and Ripply... For Emerald Coast.Heck I love Emerald Coast, period.Silly noobs, Metal Harbour and Emerald Coast beat all of you.

Edited November 23, 2011 by Vinyl Scratch

[hatok]

I some how would like to see Silver playable and Shadow for episode 3. I am curious how his powers would work with that element. Shadow and Silver would be great add ons to playable characters and rivals against Sonic. In fact, I think Shadow and Silver should work together. Also if you seen the sprite videos on them before. Silver and Shadow are not like that.

That would be impossible, and if Sonic Team did that, I'm sure that they'd lose lots of Sonic fans. Shadow and Silver really aren't that popular anymore.And besides, Sonic 4 takes place right after Sonic 3 & Knuckles. Shadow wasn't around then, and Silver wasn't either. The only possible characters are Sonic, Tails, Amy, Metal Sonic, Eggman/Robotnik, and Knuckles. And Mighty.

I remember having this conversation (I think it was with you,) about why Shadow and Silver could be included. Silver is from the future, so he would have to time-travel just like he has in every other game. Simple. Shadow was created around 50 years ago, so he would've been around before Sonic. The only real issue is that would mess up the rest of the storyline assuming it takes place right after episode 1, unless they decide to pull an 06 and retcon the whole thing.

Sega seems to have retconned Silvers time travel with Generations,

he's with Sonic and co. at the ending.

 

However

It could simply be because they were all there to provide morale support for the Sonic's after they were saved, and after Time Eater was defeated they all went back to the party, and since everyone else was there Silver didn't leave until after the game ended. Not to mention even if 06 was retconned he still time-traveled in the Rivals games which weren't retconned and were canon.

 

Guys, the answer is painfully obvious. Silver is in Generations because

Sonic Team said so.

 

The correct answer is because fanservice However, Generations actually had direct continuity to previous games, so there's nothing to imply that its effects will be undone.

[Silver the Hedgehog]

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

[Makuta Matata]

Sonic Colours > Sonic GenerationsThere, I said it.I really love Windly and Ripply... For Emerald Coast.Heck I love Emerald Coast, period.Silly noobs, Metal Harbour and Emerald Coast beat all of you.

I agree with you, Colors owns Generations. Except CD>Colors, Chaotix>CD, Unleashed>Chaotix.Well, that's my opinion.And you're the silly noob. Everybody knows that Rooftop Run ad Starlight Carnival own all. And Wacky Workbench. And Speed Slider. And Egg Fleet. And Jungle Joyride. And Eggmanland. I'll shut up now.

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game. Edited November 24, 2011 by knuckles chaotix

[PowerMiner]

I have a few questions about Sonic Generations that I hope could be answered in this topic...One: Is the 3DS version of the game all Side-scrolling? Or is there 3D gameplay in it?Two: Is the PC version of Sonic Generations basically the same thing as the PS3 or whatever console systems its on besides graphics?~PowerMiner~

[Creep Of The Deep]

1. 2.5D2. YesOh. And I bought my first Jazwares toy yesterday.Sonic & Moto Bug 3-inch figure.It's awesome. I WANT MORE JAZWARES, but they don't sell it here D:

[hatok]

I have a few questions about Sonic Generations that I hope could be answered in this topic...One: Is the 3DS version of the game all Side-scrolling? Or is there 3D gameplay in it?Two: Is the PC version of Sonic Generations basically the same thing as the PS3 or whatever console systems its on besides graphics?~PowerMiner~

Apparently, the PC version is really well optimized. It runs at a higher FPS, has no lag, and supports a lot of configuration. I'm not a first hand source here though, I'm getting this from a friend of mine who has the PC version.So, the gameplay is supposedly slightly better on a purely technical level.

[Chibinuva]

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.) Edited November 25, 2011 by Hyper Rarity

[Makuta Matata]

I have a few questions about Sonic Generations that I hope could be answered in this topic...One: Is the 3DS version of the game all Side-scrolling? Or is there 3D gameplay in it?Two: Is the PC version of Sonic Generations basically the same thing as the PS3 or whatever console systems its on besides graphics?~PowerMiner~

Apparently, the PC version is really well optimized. It runs at a higher FPS, has no lag, and supports a lot of configuration. I'm not a first hand source here though, I'm getting this from a friend of mine who has the PC version.So, the gameplay is supposedly slightly better on a purely technical level.

I've heard that it's only better if your computer has specs that far exceed the minimum requirements.

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

That's my point. Look at Shadow. When he got his own game, his gameplay was changed. Same with Knuckles and Tails. Amy has a lot of potential for awesome gameplay. Silver only has his psychokinesis, unless they decide to give him super speed like Sonic, but that's really all they could give to him. Amy could have her speed, her flight like in Heroes, HA, Invisibility, and stuff like that. Just no guns! XDAnd imagine how awesome it would be to see Super Amy!And I would also love a Chaotix game.

[hatok]

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

Amy has gameplay completely different from Sonic's. She has no speed based stuff, can't spin jump or roll, and uses various hammer attacks. And it's not like she can't have new abilities to set her apart.The Psychokinesis was NOT pretty good in 06, I'm sorry.And if anything, Generations has shown us that Silver is far to powerful to be playable.If it came down to it, I'd much sooner buy a Silver games over an Amy game, I'd prefer, y'know, ACTION

I have a few questions about Sonic Generations that I hope could be answered in this topic...One: Is the 3DS version of the game all Side-scrolling? Or is there 3D gameplay in it?Two: Is the PC version of Sonic Generations basically the same thing as the PS3 or whatever console systems its on besides graphics?~PowerMiner~

Apparently, the PC version is really well optimized. It runs at a higher FPS, has no lag, and supports a lot of configuration. I'm not a first hand source here though, I'm getting this from a friend of mine who has the PC version.So, the gameplay is supposedly slightly better on a purely technical level.

I've heard that it's only better if your computer has specs that far exceed the minimum requirements.

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

That's my point. Look at Shadow. When he got his own game, his gameplay was changed. Same with Knuckles and Tails. Amy has a lot of potential for awesome gameplay. Silver only has his psychokinesis, unless they decide to give him super speed like Sonic, but that's really all they could give to him. Amy could have her speed, her flight like in Heroes, HA, Invisibility, and stuff like that. Just no guns! XDAnd imagine how awesome it would be to see Super Amy!And I would also love a Chaotix game.

What do you mean ONLY Psychokinesis? Last I checked, the ability to manipulate any object around you was a pretty versatile ability. Also, he can fly. And if Amy can have new abilities, why can't Silver. Super Amy would be rediculous, because at that point it would seem that there's no such thing as a person who CAN'T go super.And go play Knuckles Chaotix

[Chibinuva]

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

Amy has gameplay completely different from Sonic's. She has no speed based stuff, can't spin jump or roll, and uses various hammer attacks. And it's not like she can't have new abilities to set her apart.The Psychokinesis was NOT pretty good in 06, I'm sorry.And if anything, Generations has shown us that Silver is far to powerful to be playable.If it came down to it, I'd much sooner buy a Silver games over an Amy game, I'd prefer, y'know, ACTION

I have a few questions about Sonic Generations that I hope could be answered in this topic...One: Is the 3DS version of the game all Side-scrolling? Or is there 3D gameplay in it?Two: Is the PC version of Sonic Generations basically the same thing as the PS3 or whatever console systems its on besides graphics?~PowerMiner~

Apparently, the PC version is really well optimized. It runs at a higher FPS, has no lag, and supports a lot of configuration. I'm not a first hand source here though, I'm getting this from a friend of mine who has the PC version.So, the gameplay is supposedly slightly better on a purely technical level.

I've heard that it's only better if your computer has specs that far exceed the minimum requirements.

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

That's my point. Look at Shadow. When he got his own game, his gameplay was changed. Same with Knuckles and Tails. Amy has a lot of potential for awesome gameplay. Silver only has his psychokinesis, unless they decide to give him super speed like Sonic, but that's really all they could give to him. Amy could have her speed, her flight like in Heroes, HA, Invisibility, and stuff like that. Just no guns! XDAnd imagine how awesome it would be to see Super Amy!And I would also love a Chaotix game.

What do you mean ONLY Psychokinesis? Last I checked, the ability to manipulate any object around you was a pretty versatile ability. Also, he can fly. And if Amy can have new abilities, why can't Silver. Super Amy would be rediculous, because at that point it would seem that there's no such thing as a person who CAN'T go super.And go play Knuckles Chaotix

I mean they could flesh out Psychokinesis more since while it generally refers to his Telekinesis, Psychokinesis generally means a wider range of powers. Heck, you even mentioned his flying yourself, but I want them to expand upon it more than that. For instance, astral projection like I mentioned before. It would work kinda like Kirby Super Star where you could astral project onto the physical plain, essentially copying yourself, with you controlling the body, and an AI/2nd player controlling your spirit. To prevent this from being too overpowered you'd require most of your power to astral project, meaning most of your powers would be limited if not inaccessible. Plus, it's been shown that Silver can fly quickly to make up for being slow on foot. Just give him a bar like the boost bar, but have his boost be flight, similar to in his boss fight or Super Sonic in Generations, but nerfed somewhat. Even if he is overpowered, they could always compensate by making the difficulty harder or designing the levels around his powers so it isn't too game-breaking or easy. Really, no character is overpowered unless the game allows it.

[hatok]

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

Amy has gameplay completely different from Sonic's. She has no speed based stuff, can't spin jump or roll, and uses various hammer attacks. And it's not like she can't have new abilities to set her apart.The Psychokinesis was NOT pretty good in 06, I'm sorry.And if anything, Generations has shown us that Silver is far to powerful to be playable.If it came down to it, I'd much sooner buy a Silver games over an Amy game, I'd prefer, y'know, ACTION

I have a few questions about Sonic Generations that I hope could be answered in this topic...One: Is the 3DS version of the game all Side-scrolling? Or is there 3D gameplay in it?Two: Is the PC version of Sonic Generations basically the same thing as the PS3 or whatever console systems its on besides graphics?~PowerMiner~

Apparently, the PC version is really well optimized. It runs at a higher FPS, has no lag, and supports a lot of configuration. I'm not a first hand source here though, I'm getting this from a friend of mine who has the PC version.So, the gameplay is supposedly slightly better on a purely technical level.

I've heard that it's only better if your computer has specs that far exceed the minimum requirements.

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

That's my point. Look at Shadow. When he got his own game, his gameplay was changed. Same with Knuckles and Tails. Amy has a lot of potential for awesome gameplay. Silver only has his psychokinesis, unless they decide to give him super speed like Sonic, but that's really all they could give to him. Amy could have her speed, her flight like in Heroes, HA, Invisibility, and stuff like that. Just no guns! XDAnd imagine how awesome it would be to see Super Amy!And I would also love a Chaotix game.

What do you mean ONLY Psychokinesis? Last I checked, the ability to manipulate any object around you was a pretty versatile ability. Also, he can fly. And if Amy can have new abilities, why can't Silver. Super Amy would be rediculous, because at that point it would seem that there's no such thing as a person who CAN'T go super.And go play Knuckles Chaotix

I mean they could flesh out Psychokinesis more since while it generally refers to his Telekinesis, Psychokinesis generally means a wider range of powers. Heck, you even mentioned his flying yourself, but I want them to expand upon it more than that. For instance, astral projection like I mentioned before. It would work kinda like Kirby Super Star where you could astral project onto the physical plain, essentially copying yourself, with you controlling the body, and an AI/2nd player controlling your spirit. To prevent this from being too overpowered you'd require most of your power to astral project, meaning most of your powers would be limited if not inaccessible. Plus, it's been shown that Silver can fly quickly to make up for being slow on foot. Just give him a bar like the boost bar, but have his boost be flight, similar to in his boss fight or Super Sonic in Generations, but nerfed somewhat. Even if he is overpowered, they could always compensate by making the difficulty harder or designing the levels around his powers so it isn't too game-breaking or easy. Really, no character is overpowered unless the game allows it.

Level design can't fix everything. Silver has been shown to be able to fly infinitely, be able to call objects from all over the place and shape them however he wants, and grab an enemy and throw them, without fail. Considering the fact thatSilver seems to get more and more powerful with each game he appears in, it;d be strange if hey nerfed him later.You know what I would not object to at all though? An Adventure style game with Silver as a playable character, powers intact. That would be really easy, but ridiculously fun.Plus Amy could have a reason to appear.Everybody wins.

[Chibinuva]

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

Amy has gameplay completely different from Sonic's. She has no speed based stuff, can't spin jump or roll, and uses various hammer attacks. And it's not like she can't have new abilities to set her apart.The Psychokinesis was NOT pretty good in 06, I'm sorry.And if anything, Generations has shown us that Silver is far to powerful to be playable.If it came down to it, I'd much sooner buy a Silver games over an Amy game, I'd prefer, y'know, ACTION

I have a few questions about Sonic Generations that I hope could be answered in this topic...One: Is the 3DS version of the game all Side-scrolling? Or is there 3D gameplay in it?Two: Is the PC version of Sonic Generations basically the same thing as the PS3 or whatever console systems its on besides graphics?~PowerMiner~

Apparently, the PC version is really well optimized. It runs at a higher FPS, has no lag, and supports a lot of configuration. I'm not a first hand source here though, I'm getting this from a friend of mine who has the PC version.So, the gameplay is supposedly slightly better on a purely technical level.

I've heard that it's only better if your computer has specs that far exceed the minimum requirements.

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

That's my point. Look at Shadow. When he got his own game, his gameplay was changed. Same with Knuckles and Tails. Amy has a lot of potential for awesome gameplay. Silver only has his psychokinesis, unless they decide to give him super speed like Sonic, but that's really all they could give to him. Amy could have her speed, her flight like in Heroes, HA, Invisibility, and stuff like that. Just no guns! XDAnd imagine how awesome it would be to see Super Amy!And I would also love a Chaotix game.

What do you mean ONLY Psychokinesis? Last I checked, the ability to manipulate any object around you was a pretty versatile ability. Also, he can fly. And if Amy can have new abilities, why can't Silver. Super Amy would be rediculous, because at that point it would seem that there's no such thing as a person who CAN'T go super.And go play Knuckles Chaotix

I mean they could flesh out Psychokinesis more since while it generally refers to his Telekinesis, Psychokinesis generally means a wider range of powers. Heck, you even mentioned his flying yourself, but I want them to expand upon it more than that. For instance, astral projection like I mentioned before. It would work kinda like Kirby Super Star where you could astral project onto the physical plain, essentially copying yourself, with you controlling the body, and an AI/2nd player controlling your spirit. To prevent this from being too overpowered you'd require most of your power to astral project, meaning most of your powers would be limited if not inaccessible. Plus, it's been shown that Silver can fly quickly to make up for being slow on foot. Just give him a bar like the boost bar, but have his boost be flight, similar to in his boss fight or Super Sonic in Generations, but nerfed somewhat. Even if he is overpowered, they could always compensate by making the difficulty harder or designing the levels around his powers so it isn't too game-breaking or easy. Really, no character is overpowered unless the game allows it.

Level design can't fix everything. Silver has been shown to be able to fly infinitely, be able to call objects from all over the place and shape them however he wants, and grab an enemy and throw them, without fail. Considering the fact thatSilver seems to get more and more powerful with each game he appears in, it;d be strange if hey nerfed him later.You know what I would not object to at all though? An Adventure style game with Silver as a playable character, powers intact. That would be really easy, but ridiculously fun.Plus Amy could have a reason to appear.Everybody wins.

That would work. Heck, I would have like the original Sonic Adventure games if there were like the Genesis games where you could play as different characters with the same core gameplay only with a few changes instead of being a genre-roulette (kinda like Sonic 06, but with better quality.) I wouldn't even mind Amy having the invisibility, though I'd prefer they just included the Chaotix so Espio could have his invisibility. Now to find a way to incorporate Amy, Silver, and the Chaotix into one game. Actually, I wouldn't mind another Heroes/06 style game in the sense that you have characters in groups of three. Would be cool to pair Blaze with Silver again, though unless they used Amy or made someone like Marine playable I don't know who would be the third character (or if they just omit a third character.)

[Creep Of The Deep]

STOP IT WITH THE WALLS OF TEXT D:I completed Sonic and Knuckles last Thursday.Heck yes.

[Makuta Matata]

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

Amy has gameplay completely different from Sonic's. She has no speed based stuff, can't spin jump or roll, and uses various hammer attacks. And it's not like she can't have new abilities to set her apart.The Psychokinesis was NOT pretty good in 06, I'm sorry.And if anything, Generations has shown us that Silver is far to powerful to be playable.If it came down to it, I'd much sooner buy a Silver games over an Amy game, I'd prefer, y'know, ACTION

I have a few questions about Sonic Generations that I hope could be answered in this topic...One: Is the 3DS version of the game all Side-scrolling? Or is there 3D gameplay in it?Two: Is the PC version of Sonic Generations basically the same thing as the PS3 or whatever console systems its on besides graphics?~PowerMiner~

Apparently, the PC version is really well optimized. It runs at a higher FPS, has no lag, and supports a lot of configuration. I'm not a first hand source here though, I'm getting this from a friend of mine who has the PC version.So, the gameplay is supposedly slightly better on a purely technical level.

I've heard that it's only better if your computer has specs that far exceed the minimum requirements.

I don't understand why you guys still argue about Silver being in a game. For a short time might I add. I wonderwaht you guys would say if they made Silver his own game.

They wouldn't make a Silver game, but if they did, I'd say "cool", then I'd go buy it. As long as Amy has already had her own game.

I know she has a bigger role than the "damsel in distress" but Amy's gameplay is basically the same as Sonic's but somewhat slower and with her hammer (along with usually a higher jumping height/double jump.) Given that Silver's is based around his Psychokinesis (not to mention it was pretty good in 06,) that has more potential to give him his own game. Wtih Amy being a slower, higher-jumping clone of Sonic wielding a hammer (or go one further, a copy of Blaze that has a hammer instead of Pyrokinesis, though she can't use the chaos/sol emeralds either,) there isn't much potential for her being anything more than a playable character in a regular game. Not to mention we don't know much about Silver's backstory so we could establish that, (such as how he got his Psychokinesis, though I swear I read somewhere the reasoning was "everyone has powers like that in the future.") Plus, given how much power he showed in 06 and even more so in Generations he clearly has a lot of potential to tap into. Heck, maybe they could give him a few more mind-based powers (I'd love giving him astral projection onto the physical plane so you could have his body controlled by player one and his spirit controlled by an AI/second player.)

That's my point. Look at Shadow. When he got his own game, his gameplay was changed. Same with Knuckles and Tails. Amy has a lot of potential for awesome gameplay. Silver only has his psychokinesis, unless they decide to give him super speed like Sonic, but that's really all they could give to him. Amy could have her speed, her flight like in Heroes, HA, Invisibility, and stuff like that. Just no guns! XDAnd imagine how awesome it would be to see Super Amy!And I would also love a Chaotix game.

What do you mean ONLY Psychokinesis? Last I checked, the ability to manipulate any object around you was a pretty versatile ability. Also, he can fly. And if Amy can have new abilities, why can't Silver. Super Amy would be rediculous, because at that point it would seem that there's no such thing as a person who CAN'T go super.And go play Knuckles Chaotix

I mean they could flesh out Psychokinesis more since while it generally refers to his Telekinesis, Psychokinesis generally means a wider range of powers. Heck, you even mentioned his flying yourself, but I want them to expand upon it more than that. For instance, astral projection like I mentioned before. It would work kinda like Kirby Super Star where you could astral project onto the physical plain, essentially copying yourself, with you controlling the body, and an AI/2nd player controlling your spirit. To prevent this from being too overpowered you'd require most of your power to astral project, meaning most of your powers would be limited if not inaccessible. Plus, it's been shown that Silver can fly quickly to make up for being slow on foot. Just give him a bar like the boost bar, but have his boost be flight, similar to in his boss fight or Super Sonic in Generations, but nerfed somewhat. Even if he is overpowered, they could always compensate by making the difficulty harder or designing the levels around his powers so it isn't too game-breaking or easy. Really, no character is overpowered unless the game allows it.

Level design can't fix everything. Silver has been shown to be able to fly infinitely, be able to call objects from all over the place and shape them however he wants, and grab an enemy and throw them, without fail. Considering the fact thatSilver seems to get more and more powerful with each game he appears in, it;d be strange if hey nerfed him later.You know what I would not object to at all though? An Adventure style game with Silver as a playable character, powers intact. That would be really easy, but ridiculously fun.Plus Amy could have a reason to appear.Everybody wins.

That would work. Heck, I would have like the original Sonic Adventure games if there were like the Genesis games where you could play as different characters with the same core gameplay only with a few changes instead of being a genre-roulette (kinda like Sonic 06, but with better quality.) I wouldn't even mind Amy having the invisibility, though I'd prefer they just included the Chaotix so Espio could have his invisibility. Now to find a way to incorporate Amy, Silver, and the Chaotix into one game. Actually, I wouldn't mind another Heroes/06 style game in the sense that you have characters in groups of three. Would be cool to pair Blaze with Silver again, though unless they used Amy or made someone like Marine playable I don't know who would be the third character (or if they just omit a third character.)

But more than an Amy or Silver game, I expect a Tails game. I mean, next year is his 20th Anniversary.....

[Chibinuva]

STOP IT WITH THE WALLS OF TEXT D:I completed Sonic and Knuckles last Thursday.Heck yes.

Sorry. Also, good job. I never completed any of the Genesis games save for Sonic 3 and Sonic 3 & Knuckles (pretty much skipped over Sonic and Knuckles entirely.) Since CD has save slots I probably will complete it either when I get the XBL port or the Gems Collection. I'm also thinking of playing through Sonic 1 since I now have it on Generations with infinite continues (never did get past Springyard Zone.)

But more than an Amy or Silver game, I expect a Tails game. I mean, next year is his 20th Anniversary.....

Yeah, but he did have a few games on the Game Gear which I don't think did so well. Then again, neither did ShTH and I doubt a Silver or Amy game would do that well either. *adds Tails to the list of characters in this hypothetical SA3.*

[Makuta Matata]

STOP IT WITH THE WALLS OF TEXT D:I completed Sonic and Knuckles last Thursday.Heck yes.

Sorry. Also, good job. I never completed any of the Genesis games save for Sonic 3 and Sonic 3 & Knuckles (pretty much skipped over Sonic and Knuckles entirely.) Since CD has save slots I probably will complete it either when I get the XBL port or the Gems Collection. I'm also thinking of playing through Sonic 1 since I now have it on Generations with infinite continues (never did get past Springyard Zone.)

Eh, I've played every classic Sonic game besides obscure ones like Sonic's Schoolhouse or Sonic Eraser. Well, if Sonic 3D (Saturn) and Sonic Jam count, then I haven't. And Sonic Xtreme, but that was never released.But the games I haven't played (Excluding mobile/obscure spin offs) are: Sonic JamSonic ShuffleSonic Adventure 2Sonic AdvanceSonic Advance 2Sonic BattleSonic RushSonic '06Sonic RivalsSonic Free Riders

But more than an Amy or Silver game, I expect a Tails game. I mean, next year is his 20th Anniversary.....

Yeah, but he did have a few games on the Game Gear which I don't think did so well. Then again, neither did ShTH and I doubt a Silver or Amy game would do that well either. *adds Tails to the list of characters in this hypothetical SA3.*

SA3 will probably not happen, but if it does, I want a basis in Unleashed and Adventure, NOT Sonic Adventure 2

[King Joe]

But more than an Amy or Silver game, I expect a Tails game. I mean, next year is his 20th Anniversary.....

Yeah, but he did have a few games on the Game Gear which I don't think did so well. Then again, neither did ShTH and I doubt a Silver or Amy game would do that well either. *adds Tails to the list of characters in this hypothetical SA3.*

SA3 will probably not happen, but if it does, I want a basis in Unleashed and Adventure, NOT Sonic Adventure 2

You mean gameplay-wise, not story-wise, right? Because if you throw SA2 out the window, you lose Shadow. And he's cool. Not as cool as the Blue Blur himself, but still cool.

[Silver the Hedgehog]

I think SA3 would be a great idea. Like heroes they could actually make the teams different. A good list: Team Hedgehogs:Sonic,Shadow,and Silver Team Females or something else for the name: Amy,Rouge,and Blaze Team Chaotix: Vector,Charmy,and Espio Team Sidekicks: Tails,Knuckles,and Cream(Right now this is the only third person I can think of) The last one sounded rediculous,but I am just brainstorming.

[hatok]

I think SA3 would be a great idea. Like heroes they could actually make the teams different. A good list: Team Hedgehogs:Sonic,Shadow,and Silver Team Females or something else for the name: Amy,Rouge,and Blaze Team Chaotix: Vector,Charmy,and Espio Team Sidekicks: Tails,Knuckles,and Cream(Right now this is the only third person I can think of) The last one sounded rediculous,but I am just brainstorming.

That last one? The second one sounds pretty ridiculous. In fact, so does the first one.Personally, I don't like the idea of teaming up characters based on how much they have in common, I'd ratehr see some varied characters... like Sonic Knuckles and Tails? Y'know.

[King Joe]

I think SA3 would be a great idea. Like heroes they could actually make the teams different. A good list: Team Hedgehogs:Sonic,Shadow,and Silver Team Females or something else for the name: Amy,Rouge,and Blaze Team Chaotix: Vector,Charmy,and Espio Team Sidekicks: Tails,Knuckles,and Cream(Right now this is the only third person I can think of) The last one sounded rediculous,but I am just brainstorming.

That last one? The second one sounds pretty ridiculous. In fact, so does the first one.Personally, I don't like the idea of teaming up characters based on how much they have in common, I'd ratehr see some varied characters... like Sonic Knuckles and Tails? Y'know.

Actually, I think that having Sonic Shadow and Silver on a team together sounds pretty awesome...To use Heroes-esque terminology, Sonic would be speed, Silver flight, and Shadow would be the power type with his Chaos Control.That could be pretty epic.

[Chibinuva]

I think SA3 would be a great idea. Like heroes they could actually make the teams different. A good list: Team Hedgehogs:Sonic,Shadow,and Silver Team Females or something else for the name: Amy,Rouge,and Blaze Team Chaotix: Vector,Charmy,and Espio Team Sidekicks: Tails,Knuckles,and Cream(Right now this is the only third person I can think of) The last one sounded rediculous,but I am just brainstorming.

That last one? The second one sounds pretty ridiculous. In fact, so does the first one.Personally, I don't like the idea of teaming up characters based on how much they have in common, I'd ratehr see some varied characters... like Sonic Knuckles and Tails? Y'know.

Actually, I think that having Sonic Shadow and Silver on a team together sounds pretty awesome...To use Heroes-esque terminology, Sonic would be speed, Silver flight, and Shadow would be the power type with his Chaos Control.That could be pretty epic.

Yes, but then the teams would be uneven unless of course they ramped up the difficulty ala Heroes, or gave them special attacks to make them easier, like Team Rose's blast effect of invincibility. I think they should be more grouped as usual with friends teaming up.Team Sonic: Sonic, Tails, KnucklesTeam Chaotix: Espio, Vector, CharmyTeam Blaze: Blaze, Silver, and someone else (maybe Cream if she's not on another team, or possibly Marine.)Team Dark: Shadow, Rouge, Omega.However, I'm not looking for an SA3. I'm actually looking for something closer to Sonic 06 (which kinda was an unofficial SA3,) where instead of being a genre-roulette it's also platforming, but with different characters who have different movesets. Plus, if we put Amy with Blaze and Silver then we have Amy and Silver both in the game. I also hope we either get new levels for the characters, or at least variations like in 06 as opposed to Heroes where every character ran through the same levels with slight changes that are hardly noticeable, and on top of which they all went through the levels in the same order. The changes in 06 were subtle as well, but the different characters weren't carbon-copies/reskins of each other, and they also did the levels in different orders.

[King Joe]

I think SA3 would be a great idea. Like heroes they could actually make the teams different. A good list: Team Hedgehogs:Sonic,Shadow,and Silver Team Females or something else for the name: Amy,Rouge,and Blaze Team Chaotix: Vector,Charmy,and Espio Team Sidekicks: Tails,Knuckles,and Cream(Right now this is the only third person I can think of) The last one sounded rediculous,but I am just brainstorming.

That last one? The second one sounds pretty ridiculous. In fact, so does the first one.Personally, I don't like the idea of teaming up characters based on how much they have in common, I'd ratehr see some varied characters... like Sonic Knuckles and Tails? Y'know.

Actually, I think that having Sonic Shadow and Silver on a team together sounds pretty awesome...To use Heroes-esque terminology, Sonic would be speed, Silver flight, and Shadow would be the power type with his Chaos Control.That could be pretty epic.

Yes, but then the teams would be uneven unless of course they ramped up the difficulty ala Heroes, or gave them special attacks to make them easier, like Team Rose's blast effect of invincibility. I think they should be more grouped as usual with friends teaming up.Team Sonic: Sonic, Tails, KnucklesTeam Chaotix: Espio, Vector, CharmyTeam Blaze: Blaze, Silver, and someone else (maybe Cream if she's not on another team, or possibly Marine.)Team Dark: Shadow, Rouge, Omega.However, I'm not looking for an SA3. I'm actually looking for something closer to Sonic 06 (which kinda was an unofficial SA3,) where instead of being a genre-roulette it's also platforming, but with different characters who have different movesets. Plus, if we put Amy with Blaze and Silver then we have Amy and Silver both in the game. I also hope we either get new levels for the characters, or at least variations like in 06 as opposed to Heroes where every character ran through the same levels with slight changes that are hardly noticeable, and on top of which they all went through the levels in the same order. The changes in 06 were subtle as well, but the different characters weren't carbon-copies/reskins of each other, and they also did the levels in different orders.

But with those team setups, it's exactly the same as per usual. What I would like to see is a game where the teams are a little different. I don't know exactly in which way for the others, but Sonic, Shadow, and Silver seem like an awesome combo to me.Heck, they destroyed an immortal beast together. And then erased it from existence.

[Makuta Matata]

But more than an Amy or Silver game, I expect a Tails game. I mean, next year is his 20th Anniversary.....

Yeah, but he did have a few games on the Game Gear which I don't think did so well. Then again, neither did ShTH and I doubt a Silver or Amy game would do that well either. *adds Tails to the list of characters in this hypothetical SA3.*

SA3 will probably not happen, but if it does, I want a basis in Unleashed and Adventure, NOT Sonic Adventure 2

You mean gameplay-wise, not story-wise, right? Because if you throw SA2 out the window, you lose Shadow. And he's cool. Not as cool as the Blue Blur himself, but still cool.

Yes, gameplay wise. But also story-wise. Shadow isn't a really popular character anymore. Also, I never liked him. And this Team thing is for Sonic Heroes. The only playable characters should be Sonic, Tails, Amy, Knuckles, Metal Sonic, and Big. I would love to see Espio, Vector, Charmy, and Cream appear as NPCs also. And Eggman is a given.But in all honesty, we're not getting SA3. We have Unleashed for that.

[King Joe]

But more than an Amy or Silver game, I expect a Tails game. I mean, next year is his 20th Anniversary.....

Yeah, but he did have a few games on the Game Gear which I don't think did so well. Then again, neither did ShTH and I doubt a Silver or Amy game would do that well either. *adds Tails to the list of characters in this hypothetical SA3.*

SA3 will probably not happen, but if it does, I want a basis in Unleashed and Adventure, NOT Sonic Adventure 2

You mean gameplay-wise, not story-wise, right? Because if you throw SA2 out the window, you lose Shadow. And he's cool. Not as cool as the Blue Blur himself, but still cool.

Yes, gameplay wise. But also story-wise. Shadow isn't a really popular character anymore. Also, I never liked him. And this Team thing is for Sonic Heroes. The only playable characters should be Sonic, Tails, Amy, Knuckles, Metal Sonic, and Big. I would love to see Espio, Vector, Charmy, and Cream appear as NPCs also. And Eggman is a given.But in all honesty, we're not getting SA3. We have Unleashed for that.

Yeah.But I never liked Big. He's weird.Shadow's much cooler.And Sonic Adventure 2 had a "team" system. We probably don't need more than two teams, with other characters as NPCs.

[Makuta Matata]

But more than an Amy or Silver game, I expect a Tails game. I mean, next year is his 20th Anniversary.....

Yeah, but he did have a few games on the Game Gear which I don't think did so well. Then again, neither did ShTH and I doubt a Silver or Amy game would do that well either. *adds Tails to the list of characters in this hypothetical SA3.*

SA3 will probably not happen, but if it does, I want a basis in Unleashed and Adventure, NOT Sonic Adventure 2

You mean gameplay-wise, not story-wise, right? Because if you throw SA2 out the window, you lose Shadow. And he's cool. Not as cool as the Blue Blur himself, but still cool.

Yes, gameplay wise. But also story-wise. Shadow isn't a really popular character anymore. Also, I never liked him. And this Team thing is for Sonic Heroes. The only playable characters should be Sonic, Tails, Amy, Knuckles, Metal Sonic, and Big. I would love to see Espio, Vector, Charmy, and Cream appear as NPCs also. And Eggman is a given.But in all honesty, we're not getting SA3. We have Unleashed for that.

Yeah.But I never liked Big. He's weird.Shadow's much cooler.And Sonic Adventure 2 had a "team" system. We probably don't need more than two teams, with other characters as NPCs.

Which is why I said I want it based in SA1 and SWA rather than SA2. I don't like Shadow. And Big is a baus.If not Big, then Cream or Gamma. But Cream would just be a Tails clone, just how Shadow was a Sonic clone. The only way they could make Shadow's gameplay decent is if they added motorcycles like in ShTH, and less guns. Maybe a manditory gun, but no switching. And all you can find is more ammo. That could work.But like I said before, I DO NOT WANT A SONIC ADVENTURE 3!

[PowerMiner]

Was there really a Team Metal Sonic in Sonic Heroes? I thought I heard of that somewhere.That was a loooooooooong time ago. ~PowerMiner~

[Silver the Hedgehog]

I thought Big was a useless character.Fat cat makes me go: and XD at the same time.....I still think those teams would be new and fresh....I would not even want the same teams because it makes the story seem the same and like the friends are always together. How about some change and even more friendships?

Edited November 29, 2011 by Silver the Hedgehog

[hatok]

Was there really a Team Metal Sonic in Sonic Heroes? I thought I heard of that somewhere.That was a loooooooooong time ago. ~PowerMiner~

There is, or at least, I've heard it a lot, you get it by getting all the emblems, or all the A ranks, I forget which. I've never bothered with it, just like I never bothered with Metal Sonic in Adventure, or Green Hill in Adventure 2.

[Chibinuva]

Was there really a Team Metal Sonic in Sonic Heroes? I thought I heard of that somewhere.That was a loooooooooong time ago. ~PowerMiner~

There is, or at least, I've heard it a lot, you get it by getting all the emblems, or all the A ranks, I forget which. I've never bothered with it, just like I never bothered with Metal Sonic in Adventure, or Green Hill in Adventure 2.

I hadn't heard about that. I know there's a cheat somewhere that allows you to play as any of the three main teams but reskinned so they're metallic, but never anything about unlocking Team Metal Sonic. Of course, I only recently heard about Metal Sonic in SA1 and I hadn't heard of Green Hill in SA2 until just now (when you said it,) so I probably wouldn't know. Who is on Team Metal Sonic besides Metal Sonic himself? (I would guess Tails Doll and Metal Knuckles, but I heard they were exclusive to Sonic R.)

[redacted]

I heard that rumor a lot. I think it was that supposedly, if you got all A-ranks on everything, you would unlock Team Metal or whatever, with Metal Sonic on speed, Eggman flight, and Chaos power.I never did get all A ranks, but I expect the rumor was false.

[Makuta Matata]

Guyyyys! Stop it with these sequels of Dreamcast Era stuff. If we're getting a sequel anytime soon, it'll be either Sonic Colors 2 or Sonic Unleashed 2. Or a new Storybook game.And who here has heard Crush 40's newest song?

[King Joe]

Guyyyys! Stop it with these sequels of Dreamcast Era stuff. If we're getting a sequel anytime soon, it'll be either Sonic Colors 2 or Sonic Unleashed 2. Or a new Storybook game.And who here has heard Crush 40's newest song?

I'm not specifically advocating a Dreamcast Era sequel, what I'm thinking of is a completely new game that borrows some setups that worked fairly well in previous games. Except Sonic, Shadow, and Silver are sticking together for some reason. Probably an awesome one.

[Chibinuva]

Guyyyys! Stop it with these sequels of Dreamcast Era stuff. If we're getting a sequel anytime soon, it'll be either Sonic Colors 2 or Sonic Unleashed 2. Or a new Storybook game.And who here has heard Crush 40's newest song?

Right, because it's not like the Genesis games finally got a sequel after 16 years. I'm just saying, after they finish the Genesis series reboot, making an SA3 and onward is a possibility.And no, I don't think I've heard their latest song. What is it?

[Makuta Matata]

And no, I don't think I've heard their latest song. What is it?

SONIC BOOM, SONIC BOOM, SONIC BOOOOOOM! (Save the planet from disaster!)And if there is a Sonic Adventure 3, please no Shadow or Silver. That's my only request. That, and Amy as well as Metal Sonic playable. And Unleashed gameplay.

[King Joe]

And no, I don't think I've heard their latest song. What is it?

SONIC BOOM, SONIC BOOM, SONIC BOOOOOOM! (Save the planet from disaster!)And if there is a Sonic Adventure 3, please no Shadow or Silver. That's my only request. That, and Amy as well as Metal Sonic playable. And Unleashed gameplay.

They redid Sonic Boom? I'll have to look that one up. Also, I'm not getting what you don't like about Shadow and Silver. They're cool characters. Edited November 30, 2011 by King Joe

[hatok]

Guyyyys! Stop it with these sequels of Dreamcast Era stuff. If we're getting a sequel anytime soon, it'll be either Sonic Colors 2 or Sonic Unleashed 2. Or a new Storybook game. And who here has heard Crush 40's newest song?

Erm... why?What's your reasoning behind this?

[Chibinuva]

And no, I don't think I've heard their latest song. What is it?

SONIC BOOM, SONIC BOOM, SONIC BOOOOOOM! (Save the planet from disaster!)And if there is a Sonic Adventure 3, please no Shadow or Silver. That's my only request. That, and Amy as well as Metal Sonic playable. And Unleashed gameplay.

Oh I thought you meant a new song, not a cover. Yeah, I've heard it (old news BTW,) and I for one like it as much as the original. Making me wish they had included it in Generations. Maybe when Generations gets DLC they can take advantage of the ability to swap out songs and have a song pack or two of DLC (though preferably either cheap like 100MSP or free since people with 360's can already play music through their console, not to mention other devices like phones, MP3 Players, or iPods.)