ALVIS

The "anti-canonization" camp isn't opposed to people getting confirmation on details that were left unclear. Fleshing out the powers of the Mask of Creation is a perfectly acceptable use of the LMB thread.

I agree with several who have posted above: running ideas by Greg is a helpful tool only for the purposes of resolving plot holes, filling in gaps of the story, and settling queries in BZP topics (such as whether or not Bohrok-Kal can use regular Krana). When asking to resolve a disputed matter, It's also important to give Greg both sides of the story. Boidoh, for all his enthusiasm, failed to do that when trying to settle the whole planets vs. moons fiasco, and again when trying to settle the Turaga Lhikan set debate. For example, see question #3 below. I plan to ask that question because there's now some confusion over the creation of the Skakdi Fusion, and I want BS01 to be as accurate as possible, but I want to make sure I refresh Greg's memory so he can consider all aspects of the incident. Here are some examples of the kinds of questions I think should be asked: 1. Is the Kanohi Jutlin made from Weaken disks? After all, their powers are nearly identical. (As suggested by a member on BZP.) This is a trivia question hoping to add an extra detail to a worldbuilding system that was never fully expanded on in story: the Kanoka composition of certain Kanohi. I saw someone suggest this in a BZP thread and thought it was worth asking. Whether it's canonized or not, it won't do anyone any harm. 2. In Tales of the Masks, the first book you ever wrote for BIONICLE, Onua Nuva and Turaga Whenua encounter a large, pale, tentacled worm Rahi in the depths of Onu-Wahi. In Challenge of the Hordika, Krahka assumes the form of a large, pale, tentacled worm Rahi to fight Roodaka. Was Krahka imitating a member of the species encountered by Onua and Whenua? This one is trying to simplify the story and its vast universe. We don't need two different breeds of Rahi that appear exactly the same, so I hope to get these two incarnations confirmed as members of the same species. If confirmed, it'll give Subterranean Worm another appearance for the record books, again without doing any real harm; it's just a point of trivia. 3. In Reign of Shadows, when the Toa Mahri witnessed the Skakdi creating the golden fusion, they assumed that Teridax had put the idea in the Skakdi’s minds, because only he, the Great Spirit, would know that all those beings were destined to transform. However, in an answer in this topic some weeks ago, you implied that Teridax was not responsible for giving the Skakdi that idea. If you wouldn’t mind clarifying: did Teridax manipulate the Skakdi into creating the fusion, or did he not? And if he did not, who knew, and how, that all those beings were destined to fuse? This one has much more gravity than the others, because it pertains directly to main story. We all assumed the Toa Mahri's suspicions about the creature to be accurate, because we were given no implication of anything else. However, when a LMB poster recently asked Greg a flat, "Did Teridax give the Skakdi the idea to make the fusion?", he said no, Teridax did not. I'm not sure if Greg "forgetconned" it or has actually reconsidered it and decided Teridax wasn't responsible. If Greg's answer had directly contradicted established canon, I would have gone with canon > recent answer, but since Teridax's culpability was only a theory, the truth is up for debate. Thus, I intend to ask this question, giving him the requisite background information so he can consider all angles of the incident and clear up the contention. And that's how the LMB thread should be handled.

I hated the way Kaita were handled after 2001. The introduction of Bohrok Kaita and Rahkshi Kaita contributed nothing to the story and only swelled the ranks of potential Kaita to an absurd amount. Ideally, only the Toa Mata would have been capable of forming Kaita; that would keep the numbers at a manageable level. However, since the Masters are the only Toa we've seen so far in this universe, I would not at all be averse to seeing Akamai and Wairuha make a reappearance, so long as they are accompanied by the same aura of mystery and mysticism as they were in 2001.

Put me down for recycling some of the more memorable Matoran/Turaga as Protectors. But the characters I really, truly hope to see again, even though I know I won't, are the Piraka. They simply ooze personality, and their sarcastic quips and backstabbing antics made each of their scenes a joy to read. If the new story team could resurrect them with even a fraction of the personality they had in 2006, I would be swift to proclaim this reboot continuity even better than the original.

I appreciate all of the Toa Nuva equally, with the exception of Takanuva. As others have said before me, the story team sidelined his role after 2003 and never bothered to explore his character arc. Even worse were the Toa Inika. I've read the Legends books, and I just don't understand how Greg Farshtey and the rest of the story team managed to botch the Toa Inika so badly. The Piraka oozed personality, as did Axonn, Brutaka, the Barraki, and every other character who made their debut in Legends -- but the Toa Inika were as bland as six colorful cardboard cutouts. It's curious, since they were chosen because of their unique and vibrant personalities as Matoran, but immediately upon their transformation into Toa, they lost everything that made them interesting. In retrospect, I would have much rather seen six entirely new Toa arrive on the island than bring back the Mata Nui Matoran just to mangle them. However, both Takanuva and the Toa Inika's pure boringness pale in comparison to the Toa Hagah. Like the Toa Inika, they each had unique and interesting personalities when they were introduced as Rahaga -- but immediately upon their transformation back into Toa, they dropped everything and became cookie-cutter elemental stereotypes. A reader can't tell Iruini from Matau or Norik from Jaller, nor can one tell any of the rest of the Hagah from each other. The bland, uncreative Toa we saw in Dwellers in Darkness were a far cry from the unorthodox, intriguing Rahaga we saw in Challenge of the Hordika, and it was certainly not a change for the better. All the other Toa are pretty decent. Lesovikk, Helryx, and Tuyet (even though I despise her contrived revival in Reign of Shadows) all contributed interesting personalities and motivations to the mix, and Lhikan and Nidhiki are legendary. We never really saw enough of the other Toa (Jovan, Orde, Chiara, Zaria, Varian, Naho) for me to make any real judgments on them, so I'll let them get off free. But the Toa Hagah, the Toa Inika, and Takanuva were each a complete waste of word space, and should never have been made into Toa at all.

Good choice. Adventures was Farshtey's premiere series, and it exemplifies his strengths as a writer while not being dominated by his flaws. The characterization of the Toa Metru is much deeper, more detailed, and interesting than that of the Toa Inika or Toa Nuva, and their personalities clash with and complement each other in varied and diverse ways. Additionally, Metru Nui is a rich and intriguing setting; while isolated from the rest of the universe at this time, it has a lengthy history, and there are many allusions to other locations within the Matoran universe. On top of all that, the villains are cool, and we all know that a good villain can make or break a story. So, yes, Adventures is a very good choice. If you find your appetite continues even after you've read it, I would recommend buying Legends 1-5, purely for the sake of reading up on the Piraka. Their sarcastic banter, villainous antics, and unique perspectives make every scene involving them a joy to read, and the Voya Nui story arc is heavy with tension and dramatic weight.

Who's "we"?

Well, yes, I suppose you're right. I should have said "Your social life vs. your interest in BIONICLE".

I have never seen a purer form of sheer desperation. The past is to be celebrated, but we need to move on and learn to let it go.

This already is canon; it's in its backstory in BIONICLE: Dark Hunters. If the Kraata had been exposed to energized protodermis, it would have been transformed into a Rahkshi.

There are some very enthusiastic editors on BS01, who have jumped the gun on a lot of these items. I'll ask if any of them can present tangible evidence for this, and if they can't, I will wipe it from the wiki.

I'd say this Makuta is hardly comparable to the original one. While his motivation and color scheme (after his corruption) are similar, his origins are very different. Namely, he actually is the brother of the Big Good, as opposed to a megalomaniac wannabe. He's also more sympathetic; at least, by my interpretation, he was just trying to prove he could make a really cool mask, and then everything got out of control (ironic, considering he wore the Mask of Control). However, since we've seen no actual dialogue or conversation from either him or Ekimu, it's hard to pin down any elements of his personality... all of which basically means he's not the old Makuta in any sense.

The return of BIONICLE has rekindled a lot of interest among fans, even among those whose interest had started to wane. However, many of us are older than we were, and I understand there's something of a stigma attached to high school or college age people obsessing over a LEGO toyline. BIONICLE isn't a particularly acceptable or "mainstream" fandom, unlike, say, Doctor Who, or Avatar: The Last Airbender. That leads me to hypothesize that many of its fans conceal their interests during everyday life. Now, anyone on BZPower clearly has at least some interest in BIONICLE. But outside of the Internet, how public are you about being a BIONICLE fan? I'm interested to see how secretive the community is as a whole.

(1) To remove females from the storyline would be a high offense to all ladies in the fanbase -- and there are quite a few -- and LEGO would lose a huge portion of their fans. (2) Even though it's a different universe entirely, Bionicle is based on reality's basic precepts, one of those being the existence of both male and female. If Bionicle lacked these precepts, fans could no longer relate to the characters, and almost all interest in the storyline would disappear. (3) As far as I know, many if not most of us want romance to be canonized this time around. And without females present, that would be obviously impossible. On a side note, I also hope that they don't throw in a ton of characters that never appear again / don't get a set / aren't even given a canonized appearance. You're wrong on point 3. Even if there were no female characters, there could obviously still be romance plots. Of course, LEGO probably wouldn't have the guts to include openly LGBTQA+ characters. But a man can dream.

Oh yes. =D And part of me is happy there's now not going to be a canon "future of Spherus Magna" (yet.....), so I'll feel more free to do the small sequel too. So only Greg writes stories that aren't perfectly coherent, consistent, and comfortably-sized? Well, you've got me there. But, while I enjoyed some elements of Greg's writing style, he was heavily inspired by DC/Marvel superhero comics, and that influenced him to create overly complex and convoluted plotlines. I also didn't like his philosophy of never planning ahead, and I hate that he always told BZPers who asked him about writing never to write outlines, because what works for one writer might not work for another. But I digress. The point is, this story team seems a lot more unified in vision, and the scope of their story is smaller (though it might branch out later). Both of those are promising qualities.

Someone asked Greg about this recently, and I recall pretty clearly that he said no. (You could go search the last few pages of the LMB thread if you want clear confirmation.) However, they've been shown being able to control Kanohi through more ethereal means.

Well, let's call it cautiously optimistic. We don't have a GregF yet for this generation, so that will make many BZ-Koronans nervous. By contrast -- that makes me extremely confident that BIONICLE 2015 will have a coherent, consistent, and comfortably-sized storyline.

Now, the real question is, how will you fit the Mask of Control and the Mask of ULTIMATE POWAH into this?

We already know that -- it's been confirmed a thousand times over that they would become Turaga Nuva. (Similarly, the Toa Mahri would become the Turaga Mahri and remain amphibious.) The OP's actual question is far more interesting to me, especially because I don't really have an answer. Simply based on my gut reaction, I'd say no; I think the Turaga Nuva would keep the entirety of their Nuva abilities, and any Toa they created would just be regular Toa.

I posted my interpretations of the rare breeds' habitats on tumblr a few months back. Essentially, I tried to relate their elemental affinities to the functions of the Great Spirit Robot, and see how they would have fit in.

BTW, the prefix for Shadow is Kra-, as in "Kraahkan".

I could see pretty much any male character, from Kazi to Teridax, as female or another gender, so I'm not picky about who gets switched and who doesn't. I just want the gender ratios to be less preposterously skewed.

You could add a category or sub-category for Psionic Masks, since there are so many powers that can be traced back to that element. Other than that, I don't really have any suggestions.

That's because you edited them to be that way, in error, and nobody on BS01 has the guts to tell you you're wrong and fix it. Rule of thumb: wiki is only as good as the original source of the information and the people who put it together. There's no need for name-calling. I don't like it either, but if you like, I can start a discussion on that. The go-to solution would be to re-ask Greg for clarification, but we tried that, and he just said "I'll admit I don't actually know much about physics; you shouldn't ask me about those sorts of things in the first place", without confirming or denying anything. Which leaves us... nowhere, really. *shrugs*

Respectfully, you've left out the obvious conclusion: that BIONICLE 2015 is a hard reboot, and does not, in fact, share the same continuity with the 2001-2011 BIONICLE saga. As a reboot, the line wouldn't have to consider any of the plot points that Greg introduced in the serials, since they would not even have occurred in this continuity. In a reboot, anything is possible.