Jump to content

Eyru

Premier Forum Assistants
  • Posts

    4,629
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    48

Blog Comments posted by Eyru

  1. J.R.R. Tolkien didn't just write books: he created a world. A world populated by many diverse species, each with their own language and culture. The characters you have pointed out are well-known throughout this world, so each culture knows of them, but why would they call them by one name?

     

    The elves are as different from the dwarves as you can get, and the men of Rohan and Gondor are very different culturally despite being of the same race. So why would they all call someone the same thing?

     

    These names signify different events and places. Gandalf's name changes depending on where he is and who he is with. The men and elves, being entirely different races and having completely different cultures, would not know Gandalf by the same name. If they did, that would be ignoring their cultural and linguistic differences.

     

    Side note: calling out Gandalf the Gray and Gandalf the White as different names for the same person is a ridiculous argument. :P Technically speaking, they are two different people, and anyway, calling Gandalf gray when he wears white makes no sense, so of course his name would change.

     

    EDIT: To support my argument, I've looked up the name 'John' on Wikipedia. Here's an excerpt from a list of names that John is replaced by in other languages:

     

    English ---------- John, Ewan, Shawn, Johnny, Jack, Ian, Evan

    Esperanto ---------- Johano

    Estonian ---------- Jaan, Juhan, Juho, Janno, Jukk, Hannes, Hans

    Extremaduran ---------- Huan

    Faroese ---------- Jógvan

    Filipino ---------- Juan

    Finnish ---------- Hannes, Hannu, Jani, Janne, Johannes, Juha, Juho, Juhani

    French ---------- Jean, Jehan (outdated)

    Galician ---------- Xoán, Xan

     

    It's the same name, but different cultures and languages have replaced it with their own versions.

  2. And they said it would turn out just like every other year.

     

    Who? I haven't come across any. Even I, a Hawks fan--haven't said that. No more Big Buff, so Luongo can see. Our goaltending is our greatest strength currently, with a Calder Trophy candidate who can make terrific saves on a 2 on Nobody breakaway by the last two Hart Trophy winners. He absolutely stoned the twins yesterday.

    I've met many people that don't like the Canucks because they perform well throughout the season, then crash in the playoffs and get knocked out (talking mostly about the last two years). To them, my insistence that this year is different sounds like the ravings of a diehard fan, especially when the circumstances look the same (basically, Chicago in the first round). :rolleyes:

     

     

  3. Are you kidding? The ending made no sense whatsoever. Like, what was with those words on the screen telling you who made the movie? What did that have to do with the plot?

    That confused me too. :S I couldn't remember them all.

×
×
  • Create New...