BIONICLE MAFIA: Mirror, Mirror, Split Us All

[Portalfig]

...JL just died.

[Constructelf]

Oops...

 

Lloyd then.

[Ehksidian]

I VOTE CHR-

wait he's dead

I VOTE BUR-wait no i don't think he's mafia

I VOTE RAH-wait no that's insanely obvious if he was a shadow

I VOTE FOR A SHADOW!

my logic is infalliable

we'll nab them for sure.

[Constructelf]

... wait, is it Lloyd?

 

Maybe it's Burnmad...

 

Or maybe we should have voted for Tyler...

 

... should we try getting Blade again?

 

AAAAAAUUUUUUGH FORGET I EVER VOTED!!!

[Ehksidian]

wait

NOW'S OUR CHANCE

LET US MURDERIFY BLADE TO THE DEATH

WE MIGHT GET HIM THIS TIME

I VOTE BLADE

INSTEAD OF A SHADOW

[Burnmad]

If the Cryo's gone rogue, it'd probably be better to find him...

 

It could be iBrow. He did just kill JL, after all. And Pulse said we shouldn't hang him.

 

Yeah, I switch from Tyler Durden to iBrow.

-

[Voxumo]

Hmm.. I will still trust Pulse this one time so my vote is Tyler Durden

[Toarobot18]

True, Pulse says Tyler Durden is guilty. Blade is guilty as well. Since, if I understood Zakaro correctly, that role swapper guy can't save Blade twice in a row, we might be better off lynching Blade, since the role swapper guy could have swapped Tyler.

[Burnmad]

Yeah, but like Tyler pointed out, Pulse also posted that ambiguous message about giving up sleuthing... someone ask Pulse.

 

-

Edited December 14, 2013 by Burnmad: Toa of Emoticons

[Toarobot18]

That is also true. However, I have good reason to believe that Pulse still believes Tyler is guilty. In any case, we know Blade is guilty, so I recommend getting rid of him now.

[shadow pridak money gang]

If only the Detective had survived one more round, we could prove once and for all that you shouldn't be focusing on me. I vote Blade.

 

-Tyler

[Voltex]

If the Cryo's gone rogue, it'd probably be better to find him...

 

It could be iBrow. He did just kill JL, after all. And Pulse said we shouldn't hang him.

 

Yeah, I switch from Tyler Durden to iBrow.

 

-

 

This logic seems to make sense

I vote for Voltex too

[Canis Lycaon]

...

...

Why didn't you guys post in Southern Retribution? Already this has more replies.

 

Anywho, I'll obey the will of Pulse and vote for man that started a fight club.

 

(And if you don't understand that, really?)

[Manducus]

I understand that.

 

 

 

 

 

(No not really, I merely Google'd it up)

[Constructelf]

FIIIIIIIIIINE.

 

I VOTE BLADE. SWITCH FROM NULL TO BLADE.

[Voltex]

FIIIIIIIIIINE.

 

I VOTE BLADE. SWITCH FROM NULL TO BLADE.

 

I suggest you vote for me actually

I'm a pretty bad person

[Chro]

I vote for iBrow

[Voxumo]

I would like to switch from Tyler to Tex

[Voltex]

I vote for iBrow

 

Dead people can't vote >=(

[Rahkshi Guurahk]

Then when I die I automatically vote IBrow.

[Taka Nuvia]

Voting for Blade again. I do not vote for people often but if I do, I am not happy with them surviving. :/

[Samus Aran-Bounty Hunter]

Tyler Durden- 2

Blade- 4

iBrowVolTex- 3

Zakaro

[Trijhak]

Don't send Durden to his death.

 

I think one of the following three might be a shadow: Malice, Guurahk, Norik.

 

But what do I know. I trust people too much.

 

You can send Durden to his death and kill him even though right now I've no longer got anything on him, or you can be productive.

 

Also, Cryo: the dead Pyro claims to speak on your behalf. I find that incredibly suspicious as you two are meant to be enemies.

[Canis Lycaon]

Well, if I'm not supposed to kill Durden, and Tex wants people to vote for him, I'll change my vote from Durden to Tex.

[NorikSigma]

This is

I

 

I'm suspected by Pulse?

Why

I'm innoecent.

I vote ...iBrow. I still stand by my suspicion that Blade might be innoecent. For now. And TD should be innocent.

 

TD - 1

Tex - 5

Blade - 4

Edited December 14, 2013 by Norik Of Gielinor

[Chro]

This is

I

 

I'm suspected by Pulse?

Why

I'm innoecent.

I don't think you're a very experienced Mafia player, so let me reiterate something:

There is no way to prove that you are innocent until you die.

(Obviously there are some exceptions depending on the game and the roles... but in most cases this statement holds true.)

[NorikSigma]

Of course I ain't experianced.

This is my third Mafia game(second in which I was NOT a Type 4).

[ShadowVezon]

Actually, the Detective can prove innocence most of the time. Unless Godfathers are involved. Or certain types of Detectives that are specific in their results (for example, only getting Mafia or Non-Mafia results). Or Detectives that get the wrong results. or ones that always get a certain result. But to my knowledge, at least in the Second and Third Ages there haven't been any of those types of Detective.

[Chro]

Yes, but the detective can't prove everyone's innocence... and I was talking about proving your own innocence.

[Manducus]

I'm suspected?

 

I was going with the flow of the group.

[ShadowVezon]

Well, you could show screenshots in games where the host hasn't got the rule against it. But yeah, the most you can do without a Detective is either plead, or tell them you're innocent and give a good counter argument, so when they inevitably don't listen, you can mock them about it. I get to do it every other game. It helps that I have only once been anything other then a Villager, and that was a good(ish) Mafian in Cult-IV.

Edited December 14, 2013 by ShadowVezon1

[Toarobot18]

Guys,

 

Pulse has confirmed Blade's guilt in the topic already. Blade was also saved by the mafia's swapping power, undoubtedly used to protect a mafian. He needs to be killed. You can kill someone else, but as I continue to emphasize, because Blade is a confirmed mafia, he is a better bet than your other options. I was not able to persuade the Cryo to kill Blade last round, because the Cryo was already set on killing someone else. However, I trust that the Cryo will help us going forward. If it turns out otherwise, that can be dealt with swiftly.

 

After Pulse had already resigned his investigative post, he sent me a message asking for me to arrange Tyler Durden's death. For that reason, I believed he thought Tyler Durden was still guilty. Apparently, I was wrong, although Pulse has not answered my PMs on the matter as of yet. In light of that, I do not recommend killing Tyler Durden more than anyone else on the first suspect list. Without additional information, if we are going to kill someone other than Blade, I do recommend killing someone on this first suspect list in order to narrow that list down. If we end up doing that, Blade can be dealt with through other means.

 

However, as Pulse pointed out last round, killing Tex is not a good idea, at least at this current point in time.

[Blessed Blade]

I must say; I love how you guys trust my own word on this subject. That said; not really loving the fact that you're all angry mobbing me. >>'

[Voltex]

@TR: What I like about the Cryo so far is that they are killing the people who have killed me in recent games

[Makuta of Time]

I vote Blade. For now.

[Canis Lycaon]

 

This is

I

 

I'm suspected by Pulse?

Why

I'm innoecent.

I don't think you're a very experienced Mafia player, so let me reiterate something:

There is no way to prove that you are innocent until you die.

(Obviously there are some exceptions depending on the game and the roles... but in most cases this statement holds true.)

 

Getting saved by the Medic usually confirms innocence from being a Mafian or a vigilante, depending on which tried to kill you.

 

Anywho, yes the Detective confirms innocence, but only if he reveals this.

[Samus Aran-Bounty Hunter]

Tyler Durden- 1

Blade- 5

iBrowVolTex- 5

11/18 have voted.

Voting ends at.. say, 9 AM EST. 17 hours-ish to resolve things or sooner if you group get your act together and decide mainly what you want to do.

Zakaro

Edited December 14, 2013 by ZakarOh!

[Manducus]

Switching my vote from Tyler to Blade.

[Unit#phntk#1]

Voting for Blade.

 

 

~Unit#phntk#1

[Voltex]

Unit you're up next. Or the one after, I can't remember